Ice Cream and Candy Bazaar — Restaurant in Edgartown

Whoa - this place has amazingly delicious ice cream. Being from PA, I'm used to really high quality ice cream, usually from Amish or PA Dutch sources. This ice cream was on another level though, in terms of taste and richness. When we asked about the origin, they said it came from two sources in Massachusetts and Maine. I don't know what the magic formula is, but I can say with emphatic certainty that if you enjoy ice cream... go here. Try to the Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie Dough and be prepared to enter...

I am writing this review while sitting on the dock enjoying a delicious ice cream.

Cute shop located in edgartown. I decided to go with a small, 1 scoop cone of peanut butter caramel cookie dough and it did not disappoint.

Come to ice cream and candy Bazaar and experience all 32 flavors and the great hospitality provided by the staff.

Two complaints... The sign outside says 32 flavors yet I counted 35 flavors. Second complaint is that the ice cream could be a...

Really amazing staff, I’ve gone there a few times this past summer with a daughter who has food allergies. The staff helped choose safe ice creams for her and on a few occasions opened a new ice cream container with a clean spoon so there was no cross contamination. The location is great too, it’s a bit small, but you grab your ice cream and can sit outside where there are benches. Water is close by, it’s good for a little bit...