Scoop Shack — Restaurant in Edgartown

excited to come to this eatery after reports of great lobster rolls at a price of only 7 bucks but i was immediately let down after finding they had raised the price to a horrifying 19.50 dollars! it is very shocking this business thought it could price such a dish at such a shocking price. i did try the lobster roll after hearing such brilliant stories about it and seeing the 'Islands #1 rated' plastered on the chalkboard. It was a huge letdown. The bun was limp, tasteless and unsatifactory at holding the lobster salad. the size of the lobster roll was also limited- i was exspecting something that would FILL ME UP at such a steep price but i was left hungry and deeply unsatisfied. A discarded gherkin was awkwardly placed next to a small serving of overly salty fries and I felt frustrated i had spent so much money on something which was made with little care and love. I warn all visitors to Edgartown to keep away from this eatery and not be fooled by its reputation and advertisements! If you are hungary and after something to eat i would recommend walking 5 steps further to 'A slice of Edgartown' which serves a large tasty slice of pizza at the price of 3.50 dollars. The card machine was not working which was incompetent and inept and I regret this

The price here is disrespectful and frustrating and would advise many to not invest in such a...

During our day trip to Martha’s Vineyard, we looked for an ice cream shop in Edgartown. They had a few to choose from, and we tried Scoop Shack.

They had more than just ice creams, but candies, toys, and other souvenirs. It was a nice size shop, but didn’t offer any table or chair, which was a bummer.

They had a cute posters on the wall that said “Frozen Green Tea with mint and Honey” and “Frozen Root Beer.” But when I asked about those flavors, the staff told us they don’t make them any more… So, don’t trust the flavors on the side wall… The very colorful menu on the center wall is current, and unless they sold out of some flavors, they are the ones that they actually offer.

We got Brown Sugar Banana flavor and Butterbeer flavor ice creams. Banana one was so creamy, almost mushy than creamy, like mashed banana. I really liked it! Butterbeer one was not quite like the ones from The Wizarding World of Harry Potter in Universal Studios. This one here had similar flavor to Root Beer, but much more tasty.

The staffs were not overly friendly but nice enough. We enjoyed their ice cream, and we were lucky enough to find a bench nearby. Great spot for a very...

HOSTILE TO FOOD ALLERGIES. Believing that “homemade ice cream” made on the premises was a good bet for telling us wether particular flavors had eggs or nuts we made two attempts here and in both cases, staff was unwilling to be helpful in any way, telling us, in one instance, that they “cross contaminate all the containers anyway so we shouldn’t try to find out ingredients.” Disgraceful. We have often found that one of our party can’t eat at a particular place but have never been met with rudeness. I guess the line out the door means more than being...