McAlister's Deli — Restaurant in Fishers

Shout out to Mary, Aurora, Carter, Rachel, Brandon, and that one awesome guy with the beard and the ponytail who says "good morning" no matter what time it is. There's more on the same shift, but sorry I can't remember all your names! You all make my day every time I see you. In terms of friendliness and team camaraderie, this Fishers location probably has the best and most cohesive team. Awesome customer service, always eager to get to know the customers, they work quickly and accurately, and you always leave happier than when you went in. Other locations, take note! Corporate also needs to take note of the great things they're doing here and approve more raises and bonuses at this location. God bless you all!

The Fishers location also stands out with their incredible chocolate chip cookies, freshly baked in-house. Soft, doughy, and every bite is so delicious (see the attached photos). Wow! Other locations, take note; this right here is how to make a cookie!! Buy these cookies here and not the hard cookies that other locations have.

Check out the Fishers location for their amazing spuds as well!

McAlister's Deli is wonderful! They have delicious and healthy sandwiches, salads made with clean and fresh vegetables, the best spuds you'll ever eat, and best of all, McAlister's Famous Tea!!! 🍵 The sandwiches and salads are at the same price point as that of Panera Bread, and it's apparent that McAlister's Deli is a competitor to Panera. But what sets McAllister's Deli apart in the higher-end sandwich and salad industry is McAlister's Famous Tea! 🍵

The tea is an experience. Make sure to fill your cup to the brim with ice, because McAlister's Deli brews its tea strong and hot. The tea is a perfect combination of flavors, from the earthy bitterness from the premium black tea leaves, balanced by the zing of freshly squeezed lemon! To top it off, add a couple shots of real fruit puree! The best combination is the peach tea. 🍑 🍵 Recommendation: Add two or three pumps of peach puree 🍑 to a glass of unsweetened tea 🍵, and squeeze in two or three slices of lemon. 🍋 The result is perfection! Like a hug in a glass, just the right amount of fruity sweetness, and an excellent source of vitamin C! 🍋

Other recommendations:

Savannah chopped salad 🥗, with Sherry shallot dressing; Pecanberry salad 🥗, with Sherry shallot dressing; Colossal carrot cake 🥕 🍰; Chocolate chip cookie (get these soft and delicious cookies at the Fishers location, and avoid the hard cookies at other locations); Spicy southwest chicken 🐣 🪓 ➡️🍗🥑; and Spud max, but also add avocado, extra green onions, and extra butter! Perfect with a side of tomato and cucumber salad.

5/5;...

My wife and I got carryout on the evening of Friday, January 6. I subsequently completed a survey emailed to me by McAlister's asking for a review of our experience. I gave the overall experience 2 stars (same as on my Google review). I noted in their survey that 1. My wife's harvest chicken salad sandwich on croissant had very little chicken salad on it. She noted that the sandwich did not look at all like the picture in the McAlister's app. 2. I have a $100 McAlister's gift card, for which I can find no way to pay with an order thru the app. So I called this McAlister's and got an electronic something-or-other which took my order. Order was correct when I got to the restaurant, and I was able to use my gift card. I was charged 61 cents for placing the order over the phone to this electronic system. I received an email after completing the survey from someone named Melissa Myers at McAlister's. Said that this was a "high-volume location" and the service fee was from a 3rd party that took my phone call and order. There was no offer to refund the service fee. Nor was my wife's lack of chicken salad on her croissant ever addressed. Generally, a chirpy email, with no remedies. Nor is there apparently any way to use a McAlister's gift card in their app. Which was also not addressed in Melissa Myer's email to me. Overall, an unsatisfying experience, worthy of at most a...

Im so very upset with McAlisters. Have neen2 for the past few years but I keep hoping they'll "get better". A large group of friends used to go every Friday night after volleyball and spend money there. Food was good, reasonably priced and staff were great! Now, the food is just meh, the prices are riculous and the staff are also meh, uncaring and unable to think for themselves. Most recent trip...I asked how full they fill the nacho cheese in the to go cup (Ive been very disappointed in the past) He said " If you do the pick 2, we fill it about 1/2 full. If you do the regular memu item, we fill it about 3/4 full. What?? Why?? We're paying you the whole price, why dont we get a full cup? Ugh. Needless to say, I didnt get to order my favorite menu item. The boyfriends order was mostly jipped of all the ingredients for his ultimate nachos. Luckily he went thru it before leaving and got a few toppings they forgot and was given more of some toppings that barley had a trace in the containers. This was our last trip. Very sad and confused as to how they think people won't notice. Maybe a first...