Peace Pie in St. Augustine is a delightful and unique dessert destination that takes the ice cream sandwich to an extraordinary level. This charming little shop, nestled in the heart of St. Augustine, offers a whimsical and nostalgic atmosphere that's instantly inviting.The concept of Peace Pie is simple yet brilliant - layering delicious ice cream with a slab of delectable pie filling between two scrumptious cookies. The variety of flavors is impressive, ranging from classic combinations to more adventurous and creative pairings. Each Peace Pie is a work of art, perfectly balanced in flavor and texture.What makes Peace Pie stand out is not just the quality of their desserts but also the warmth and friendliness of the service. The staff are enthusiastic and helpful, making recommendations and sharing the story behind this unique dessert concept.The shop is clean, cozy, and beautifully decorated, adding to the enjoyable experience. Whether you're a local or a visitor in St. Augustine, stopping at Peace Pie is a must for a memorable and tasty treat that brings a smile...
Read moreThe peace pie itself was okay, but the atmosphere and experience were not worth the money or effort . The peace pie is not made on the spot; it's pulled out of a freezer pre-made. It seemed like getting a frozen treat from a box from Costco. It's served in a flimsy tissue paper. They don't even have bowls or spoons if you ask for one, so prepare to get messy. Also, the shop was being run by one person. It wasn't crowded, but the worker apparently didn't have time to wipe down the two tables, which were covered in sticky dried up ice cream. Gross! So I tried my best to mop it up for them by pouring water from the water bottle I purchased there, with the one little napkin I was able to scavenge. Honestly, I hate getting that messy and really dislike feeling rushed to eat my frozen treat to the point I couldn't enjoy it. The guy who worked there commented that he was annoyed that he didn't have time to make himself a milkshake since more customers kept showing up. I don't plan on annoying him with my...
Read moreIce cream sandwich was okay, but I don't think I'd buy again considering the price. That's a none issue, though, because I'd really never go back due to the poor customer service. The girl at the counter was perfectly friendly, but the manager or owner made us feel extremely uncomfortable as we tried to eat our sandwich. When we entered the place at just before 7, there was a sign on the door saying it was closed from 8-9. We bought a sandwich and sat down. A couple minutes later, they changed the sign to 7, with said manager going on about not wanting to have to redo everything. Another family came in as this was happening, bought a couple ice cream sandwiches, and tried to sit down. They were told to leave. As she continued to huff and puff about the place, we felt increasingly uncomfortable and told her not to worry, we'd be leaving soon. About a minute later, she asked if we were leaving. This was before 7:10. I assured her we were and we promptly left that unwelcoming...
Read more