NY Pie (Hendersonville) — Restaurant in Hendersonville

I ordered pick up after following a thread on Facebook about the best New York style pizza in the Nashville area. NY Pie was mentioned a couple times and I was running errands in Hendersonville so I decided to call it in. I ordered an 18-in cheese pizza and added mushrooms. There is an option when you check out to add garlic at no charge so I opted for that. I picked up the pizza and immediately had a slice in my car. At first notice the dough is pretty tough and not soft and chewy in the NY sense that you can fold it over easily. Second, I could not taste any garlic whatsoever. Whether the garlic is a powder or added into the sauce, or baked on top I could not find any visual representation of garlic and couldn't taste any either. The pizza sauce is fine, a little on the sweet side. The pizza itself can definitely use more cheese and also more sauce. I found it to be a little scant on both although the good grease was there but only on top of the pizza, not soaked through the dough enough to where it makes your paper plate or to go box nice and slightly greasy - there was just not enough cheese to make that top layer gooey enough either. Definitely little on the dry side to be called NY Pie. I was really hoping for something satisfying and I'm left...

The pizza was pretty good, garlic knots were ok, but not worth the price point or the atmosphere. People had to stand around waiting for a seat to open in various places throughout the restaurant…just hoping their food wasn’t ready before someone got up to provide a seat to actually eat. The set up is all wrong. There is no waiting area in the front so people actually stood and waited beside tables where others were trying to enjoy their meal. It was chaotic and when asking for a table to be cleaned off (someone finally finished and we saw an open seat) it was rushed, we had to stand in the aisle and wait, and the table was barely cleaned. We had to finish cleaning the table off ourself. It would have been better if we ordered carry out from Dominos and ate in our car. Parking was also not ideal, only one bathroom stall, and the price point is too high for what you get. I would only stop in IF it’s an off time. Maybe you will get friendlier service and be able to eat your pizza in a more peaceful laid back atmosphere. Don’t go out of your...

Omg......I'm originally from the Chicago area. We are ad serious as New York.about pizza. And it is common knowledge that the best pizza is in either of those places. Domino's is good pizza. Pizza hut is as well,. But when I say good, that's just exactly what I mean. Good. Not Great or excellent. You get great or excellent pizza in almost any mom and pop Chicago area pizza place. Am sure New York is similar. In Nashville area I have only found ONE GOOD.....no take that back.....ONE PLACE SELLING EXCELLENT PIZZA. NY PIE. This is the second one I have eaten at, and both are EXCELLENT. Only one problem exists........if you haven't been to Chicago.....or New York, chances are high that you have never had top notch pizza. You can somewhat remedy that by going to NY PIE. It is not "CHICAGO," pizza.......but it is NY pizza, and It is EXCELLENT. THE TWO NY PIE stores that I have been to, were clean, served hot food, and the people were super. If you want R E A L pizza.....try NY PIE. You will...