Famous Calabria Pizza — Restaurant in New York

Ive been here several times and spend a lot of money here food is good! Especially the salad but Terrible customer service this time I walked in being challenged by one of the employees! The employee was going back and forth with me rudely about what I didn’t order previously to coming which I wanted again and that was a small side of Greek salad that I ordered several times along with other items… he was consistently saying rudely that hasn’t been done in years and I let him know that I recently brought it; there was no issue I don’t understand why I’m getting this response now; being that he wasn’t the the one that did the side salad but the owner did he wanted to continuously argue me down about it! I told him several times the conversation was over it’s okay I know what I ordered just say it’s no longer available and move on with my new order. He didn’t and kept speaking on the side salad…so I proceeded to leave not getting my money and being treated rudely! As I’m leaving he said “don’t ever come back here again” I told him your Boss won’t be too please with you being rude to customers and also losing business b/c you couldn’t control your ego! I told him you don’t ever have to worry about me coming into this place again this isn’t the only place to eat to be mindful of that when you decide to allow your ego to overpower you! I’m one person imagine him being rude to several others! LOSING BUSINESS to customers that frequently go to your store isn’t a good look! Sorry to the owner but your employee differently needs an attitude adjustment and thank you for the service I did receive and I enjoyed the salads but I can no longer give this place business.

(Service 2 stars b/c of what happens) other then that several of the employees are welcoming and accommodating.

Update: thanks for the reply…I didn’t go into the establishment but I did have someone order me a salad yesterday 9/7/23. My review wasn’t to bring down the business but to bring awareness to how one of your customers was treated which was me. I never experienced that before going there so it was a major shock…. I love the salad and other things…so just for recognizing my review and replying respectfully I appreciate that. I always recommend this place for a salad every etc. even if I’m not...

Best fresh pizza I have had in a long time! On behalf of my mother, Maria, and myself, Brian, we absolutely love this pizzeria. We've been loyal customers for over five years now, and it’s incredible to think about how long it has been. Yet, despite the passing years, one thing remains consistent—the food is always delicious, and the quality never wavers.

Every bite of their pizza is a reminder of why we keep coming back. The crust is perfectly baked—crispy on the outside, yet soft and airy on the inside. The sauce has the right balance of tangy and sweet, and the cheese is always fresh, melted to perfection. Whether it’s a classic cheese pizza or one of their specialty pies, we’ve never been disappointed.

But what truly sets this place apart is that their menu goes beyond just incredible pizza. Their burgers are packed with flavor, always juicy and cooked just right. Their gyros are another must-try—tender, well-seasoned meat wrapped in warm pita bread with fresh toppings and the perfect amount of sauce. The beef patties are full of rich, savory goodness and a great snack if you’re in the mood for something quick yet satisfying. And let’s not forget their salads—fresh, crisp, and full of vibrant flavors that complement any meal.

Beyond the amazing food, the service here is truly top-notch. The staff is always welcoming, attentive, and incredibly kind. They go above and beyond to make every customer feel valued. It’s not just about serving food; they genuinely care about their customers, making each visit a warm and enjoyable experience.

This pizzeria has become more than just a place to grab a meal—it feels like home. If you’re looking for fresh, flavorful food made with care and served with a smile, this is the place to go. No matter what you order, you’re in for a treat. Highly...

CUTE PIZZARIA WITH A GREAT CATERING EDGE:

I’ve walked past this pizzeria umpteen times. Calabria Pizza looked cute and inviting especially at night with their lighting from outside. I’m glad I finally tried it as it was an interesting visit.

It is a little nook on the Lower East Side that provides a casual break spot for a simple meal. They also run, a burgeoning catering business.

They have an enormous menu, which ain’t cheap but given their portion sizes, makes sense to some extent. The best things on this menu are the spaghetti Alfredo and the Greek salad, which I had with shrimp. Simply fresh, flavorful and delicious. My all time favourites.

The pizza slices are enormous - as are the portions of all the other dishes. I found the slices somewhat salty but a tasty meal in and of itself. I cannot recommend the pizza ensalata enough! So healthy with a soft pizza crust and fresh salad on top! The the grilled chicken pizza slice. Tender and perfectly roasted Caesar chicken chunks on a perfect pizza dough.

They make their own soda pop which is quite delightful. Although I am not partial to ever having carbonated soda drinks due to high sugar levels and my fitness regimen, Calabria’s pineapple and lemonade pop flavors tingled and enticed my taste buds quite refreshingly on an almost spring day.

If you like your pizza and pizza service like I like my pizza crust, rough around the edges but soft and, crisp and delicious inside, this is the spot for you!

I highly recommend this spot for catering your events, casual meals and of course, take out!...