Good Enough To Eat
Good Enough To Eat things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
Happy St. Patrick’s Day! Who wants one from @goodenoughtoeat? 🍰🍀 See the full list of our favorite ways to celebrate today in NYC at our link in bio @NYbucketlist ⬅️ #NYbucketlist #nyc #stpatricksday
nybucketlistnybucketlist
4.6K46
NYC Must-Try List | Family-Friendly Edition | Neighborhood Guide
synth.lifesynth.life
4880
tl;dr Called to order Item A, but was given Item C. When I noticed the mistake once home, I called back requesting Item A. Waiter **insists** that I said Item B, but since Item B doesn't exist he gave me Item C. The combativeness and gaslighting was weird, therefore 1-Star and not 'Good Enough To Eat' here again. Called to place an order for pick up. Waiter put me on hold to help someone else for a few seconds, then took my order. I ordered a Lumberjack and a Classic Grilled Cheese. Picked up the order 20 min later, right on time. Unfortunately, the order was wrong. I was given a Reuben rather than a Classic Grilled Cheese. When I called to rectify the situation, the waiter **insisted** that I "ordered a Roast Beef Sandwich, and since there is no Roast Beef Sandwich, [Good Enough to Eat] gave us a Reuben because that's the closest thing." I confirmed that I didn't order a Roast Beef Sandwich and requested a Classic Grilled Cheese. Mistakes happen; whatever. Not a big deal. I asked if I could pick up a Classic Grilled Cheese now. They were resistant at first but then said that we could get a Grilled Cheese. They asked if I wanted him to add it to the bill, and I told him that I wanted it comped since they gave me the wrong order (this is literally like... $1.25 worth of ingredients?) The waiter **insisted** that I had ordered a Roast Beef Sandwich and was given a Reuben because they don't have a Roast Beef Sandwich. A few rounds of "No, I never said anything about Roast Beef" and "Yes you did" ensued. The waiter insisted the manager would not approve a comped Classic Grilled Cheese because this was all my fault. It was weird that the waiter double and triple downed that it was me who ordered the wrong thing, when the reality is that... No. One. Ordered. A. Roast. Beef. Sandwich. There was no apology, or empathy, or desire to find a solution. Just pure gaslighting. And even if I had ordered a Roast Beef, why would they take that order and knowingly plan to give me a Reuben, but not warn me beforehand?!? "Hey, we don't have a Roast Beef Sandwich. We do have a Reuben though; do you want that?" To which I would have responded with "No, I said Classic Grilled Cheese. I want a Classic Grilled Cheese." It's just. Weird. 1-Star. Do not recommend. Will go to Cafe 82 next time I'm in the mood for diner comfort food.
Henry AeryHenry Aery
20
A regular brunch place I frequent during Saturday that entails staying uptown or no plans whatsoever. My dining partner and I usually order the same dishes and it has been consistently delicious. Our go to is the stacked pancakes (sweet) and corned beef hash with eggs (savory). The stacked pancakes are made with a mix of flour and cornmeal. The strawberry butter spread and topped with Vermont syrup makes the pancake stacks undeniably delicious! It has actually inspired us to look for a cornmeal pancake recipe and we have replicated this dish, but as strawberry pancakes. The strawberry butter is still something we need to attempt to make. The corned beef hash is definitely homemade, filled with chunks of thick meat. My dining partner would also order the lumberjack because of the thick cut bacon. The bacon has an even amount of meat and fat, with the sweetness and savory taste to it. I have only dined here during brunch time, weekdays and weekends. The place does get packed during popular times, which we try to avoid dining in those times. Since outdoor dining has become a thing, their square footage has increased, accommodating more diners. The cup of brewed coffee is delicious and with free refills. There is a trend in NYC restaurants that do not offer compliments of refills and you can amplify your jitters with a cup or three in this restaurant ! The service is attentive and can get European when they are busy, but the atmosphere is inviting to chat with your dining partner as you wait for your meal.
Sonia MaeSonia Mae
100
Quint place. Cool area. Most of the food was good. Shank steak was ok. Bland. Salsa was bitter and did not add to the taste. Daughter liked the mac'n'cheese. Son liked the burger. Rest was ok. Where this really fell down was the service. New guy or not...he HAS to do more than poor water for his guests. My order wasn't put in so I ate while the rest watched. Salad came just before main course. Server never checked in on us...not once and when ready to pay...no where to be found. Another server had to come help. We were there around 6 on Saturday but the place was not busy. There are lots of options for food on this stretch of the area. I'd try somewhere else based on this experience...owner/manager came by and had a chance to try to make things right.... didn't discount or give us anything as compensation...even after he was told about the experience.....guess he didn't care either....won't be back
Jeremy DJeremy D
00
Very pleasant atmosphere. I had a quinoa salad, the best I’ve ever had. Very refreshing and a huge amount.
Fathia AkamazinaFathia Akamazina
10
Nearby Attractions Of Good Enough To Eat
Central Park
American Museum of Natural History
Theodore Roosevelt Park
Belvedere Castle
AMC 84th Street 6
Children's Museum Of Manhattan
Arthouse Hotel New York City
The Great Lawn
Marshalls
The Great Lawn

Central Park
4.8
(80.5K)Click for details

American Museum of Natural History
4.5
(8.3K)Click for details

Theodore Roosevelt Park
4.6
(4.8K)Click for details

Belvedere Castle
4.5
(2.9K)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Good Enough To Eat
Levain Bakery – Original Location, 74th St, NYC
Jacob's Pickles
Carmine's - Upper West Side
Shake Shack Upper West Side
French Roast
Maison Pickle
Jing Fong
Levain Bakery
Playa Betty’s
Crumbl - Upper West Side

Levain Bakery – Original Location, 74th St, NYC
4.7
(2.9K)Click for details

Jacob's Pickles
4.6
(2.8K)Click for details

Carmine's - Upper West Side
4.4
(2.7K)$$
Click for details

Shake Shack Upper West Side
4.2
(3.4K)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
520 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024
Map
Phone
(212) 496-0163
Call
Website
goodenoughtoeat.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.1
(927 reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Traditional American comfort fare and house-baked treats, featuring locally sourced ingredients.
attractions: Central Park, American Museum of Natural History, Theodore Roosevelt Park, Belvedere Castle, AMC 84th Street 6, Children's Museum Of Manhattan, Arthouse Hotel New York City, The Great Lawn, Marshalls, The Great Lawn, restaurants: Levain Bakery – Original Location, 74th St, NYC, Jacob's Pickles, Carmine's - Upper West Side, Shake Shack Upper West Side, French Roast, Maison Pickle, Jing Fong, Levain Bakery, Playa Betty’s, Crumbl - Upper West Side

- Please manually select your location for better experience