Good Judy — Restaurant in New York

The bartenders aren’t on the same page for the page with the covid policies. One time I went in and wasn’t asked for my vaccine paper. One time I went in and was asked for it.

I didn’t have my phone with me that second time and spent ten minutes trying to get my passport on my friend’s phone. I couldn’t retrieve it and was told to leave and come back with it.

Ironically while I was searching for my paperwork I was allowed to stay in the bar. Anyway, I left and came back with my covid passport and the bartender never even asked to see it!

The whole experience felt very unwelcoming and tainted the bar for my friend and I.

If covid is such a priority for Good Judy, why are the actions so...

Look, it's great this bar offers Saturday celebrations on 5th Ave and ppl always have a good time. BUT for the sake of your neighbors PLEASE can you offer more bathrooms or something. People are drinking then peeing right outside our apartment building on the corner of 16th St and 5th ave. They pee squatting behind parked cars and today they were peeing INSIDE our external stairwells (which is BTW private property). Like if you can't hold it in, and you gotta pee, whatever, but there are kids around!!!! Is this what you want to bring to the neighborhood????? It's been going on last year and this year and I'm so sick and tired of this...

This place is truly a hidden gem! The cocktail menu gives you sort of a speakeasy vibe, you can bring outside food and eat it at the tables when you first walk in which was nice. They have an upstairs witch is a piano bar, a long bar downstairs (with some narrow tight squeezes as the place get busy) then you hit a nice size dance floor (shout out to DJ Savage!!! Who played great music and kept the flow of the crowd going all night). And then they have a beautiful back door patio (for the smokers and people who don’t mind). It is just a few stops outside of the City so if you are debating on it… YES!! Take the trip to Good Judy… You will...