The Garage — Restaurant in Sister Bay

Worst fish taco I’ve ever eaten in my life . Ya have a grill in the whitefish capital of the world , you should make a fish taco that people brag about . And it wasn’t just that it tasted horrible, it’s that the fish portion was ridiculously small . That being said , the atmosphere was typical outdoor sports bar , decent music , adequate seating. The drinks was the only thing that saved it for me . The gal made a legit margarita which ,if you’re a margarita drinker , is pretty rare in Wisconsin. Most bars in Wisconsin for some reason usually use old spoiled pre mix junk in their margaritas instead of fresh ingredients and high quality tequila. The Garage at least used a fairly fresh mix and decent tequila. Best margaritas in the state so far are at Tavern on...

We had to park around the block, which was only a quick walk. We each got one of the drink specials, and they were horrible. Burnt and/or bad mixture idk, anyhow we had to chase them down with a burrito. The burrito was average but good. Service was an "order at the bar and we'll bring it to you method since we sat on the outdoor back patio. We bought the adult slushies to make up for it (Pina colada and strawberry daiquiri), these were delicious but $10/each. You can get these with no alcohol, boozy, or...

Great spot to get cocktails and relax while moving about this cute town. Great friendly staff, knowledgeable and helpful with recommendations for the area. Highly recommend going alo during evening after 8pm to catch live music - band was great and audience was having a great time! And yes get the spicy Paloma 😋 while you are at it say 👋 to Darrin at the garage serving the best drinks and info...