Door County Creamery — Restaurant in Sister Bay

Door County Creamery is an exceptional restaurant that truly delights the taste buds. From the moment we stepped in, we were greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The team was incredibly friendly and attentive, making our dining experience all the more enjoyable.

We started off with their gyro and burrata salad, and we were blown away by the freshness of the ingredients. The gyro was packed with succulent meat and accompanied by a medley of vibrant vegetables. The flavors were perfectly balanced, creating a mouthwatering combination that left us craving more.

The burrata salad was a work of art. The creamy burrata cheese paired wonderfully with the crisp greens and a variety of delectable toppings. Every bite was a burst of freshness, and the attention to detail was evident in the presentation.

Not only did Door County Creamery excel in their culinary offerings, but their commitment to using super fresh ingredients was truly commendable. It’s evident that they take great care in sourcing high-quality produce, which elevates the overall dining experience.

The restaurant’s team deserves special praise for their exceptional service. The team members were incredibly polite, accommodating, and knowledgeable about the menu. They went above and beyond to ensure our needs were met, making us feel welcomed and valued as guests.

Overall, our experience at Door County Creamery was nothing short of fantastic. The combination of super fresh ingredients, flavorful dishes, and attentive service creates a dining experience that is truly memorable. Whether you’re craving a gyro or looking to indulge in a delightful burrata salad, this restaurant is a must-visit. We can’t wait to return for another extraordinary...

Ya had me at goats milk gelato!!!!!❤️‍🔥

We’ve been coming to this restaurant for years. They offer a beautiful variety of handcrafted gelato and a small classic section of Panini sandwiches.

This is not a huge restaurant. I would qualify it as a quaint diner style more mom and pop with handcrafted goodies.

If you’re looking for something with fast service, this is not it because the staff takes their time and handcrafts each item just for you so if there’s a crowd, please be patient. The staff is amazing very helpful and friendly. They do their best to accommodate everyone soulfully

I adore their vanilla olive oil gelato. When the manager first recommended this to me a few years ago, I was hesitant, but she offered me a sample and I was hooked. Since then, it is my favorite and they even ship!!❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

They also make the best Turkey Panini I have ever had in my life. Everything is so darn fresh on the sandwich. It is black out good!!!❤️‍🔥

They offer a few small tables inside as well as out.

If you were looking to get waited on quicker, May, I recommend trying this place during the week slightly before dinner time to avoid the rush.

The food here is so spectacular that if you come by on the weekend, they will most likely have a mob of people. But you know it’s just that darn good.

Thanks to the staff for working so hard and taking good care of us.

We look forward to getting back to town and were delicious restaurant ASAP.

Namaste...

09/2023 Update: This is a must-stop if you're anywhere close to Sister Bay. They've re-vamped their menu, but the quality is still the same as it ever was - superb.

The Hot Honey & Chevre sandwich was excellent. Kind of like a spicy/sweet Italian sandwich. The Reuben sandwich was my favorite and will be the sandwich by which all other Reubens are measured against. HOWEVER, if you have to get just one, make it the Meatball Sandwich. This one was so amazing that it made my wife change our plans so we could order another one to-go on our last day in DC. We had to get another cooler and find ice packs...it was a whole thing. And I can personally vouch that the quality of the sandwiches holds up to a reheat in the microwave/oven - just as good as the day it was made. Also, an extra special shout-out to the staff who let us order the sandwich even though it was technically still "breakfast" time.

Original Review: Always delicious, with super friendly staff, and a cozy and relaxed atmosphere. It's a must-stop for food lovers.

We've been vacationing in Door County annually for about 8 years and we always make time for Door County Creamery. The feta and giardiniera sandwich is something we talk about throughout the year -...