Just Like Magic Bakery — Restaurant in Stroudsburg

Updated Review: This is now my 3rd visit to Just Like Magic and still very impressed with the quality of the baked goods! So tasty and fresh. My favorite treat this time was the Peanut Butter Lovers cupcake! yum!

Excellent service from staff and the decor reminds me of something magical! Looking forward to my 4th visit soon!

Original Review: What an awesome bakery! Paula, the owner was so pleasant and made us feel like old friends! We will be back soon for some more of the sweet delights here!

Bought several different cupcakes...all were so tasty! (the sea salt caramel cupcake, vanilla cupcake with chocolate icing, the butterscotch cupcake - my favorite, and the vanilla oreo cupcake) wanted to try all of the treats here. Freshly made breads also sold here.

Lots of art by a local artist featured here, and adorable seating areas if you want to hang out and eat your treats right away. A good variety of beverages also sold.

We are from out of town and can't wait to get back here soon!

oh and make sure to say hi to Bertha at the entrance. You...

Just Like Magic Bakery is true to their name.

I had been looking for a bakery that can create custom cakes without causing me to sell my kidneys, and this store did just that.

The manager, Paula, was very attentive and easy to talk to. She listened to what I wanted, offered insights, and set reasonable expectations.

On the day of the pickup, the sales associate, Troi, welcomed me with a very sunny smile. She did not make me feel awkward nor alienated inside the store. She had a pleasing personality.

The store itself is very quaint, clean, and presentable. They had other delicious products in whimsical designs that are clearly made with quality abd care.

As for my actual cake, i was very happy with the output. The actual cake closely matched the original design. The chocolate flavor was delicious - it wasn't overly sweet. Just Like Magic Bakery brought the idea to life.

The whole experience was just surreal and wondered

Just....

I popped in on my walk down Main St decided I'd bring the family home a treat. I ordered the few things I wanted & used the ladies room. When I came back out, moments later, a line formed. My items were boxed & ready to go, just needed to pay. The girl behind the counter took 2 other customers, 1 was quick, then she took another one wanting to order a wedding cake & of coarse she had a lot of questions, I would too!

Cashier should have said, plz excuse me quickly while I ring this woman up. Would have taken 30 seconds & I could have been on my way, but nope I stood there for 15 mins! She never even made eye contact to tell me she'd be right with me, nothing. I left.

(She also said, she had no idea what was in one of the cake pops. I wanted to know what flavor of cake was inside. How can u sell something you know nothing about?! ) LOL!

I'm not rating the food bc I didn't try it, im only rating the service bc...