Lancaster Pie & Coffee — Attraction in Lancaster

Words cannot express how wonderful Lancaster Pie and Coffee is. I also want to note that I have been a huge fan for a while. We wanted to have pie instead of cake for our wedding, and they made it beyond easy to help us. Micah is an actual angel who made the entire process seamless and enjoyable, all while being the sweetest person ever. The day of the wedding, he personally delivered the pies to our venue and put them away for us. We also needed a few pies for some people with dietary needs, and he happily offered us a solution (W Donuts!). That recommendation took a ton of stress away when it came to looking for those options.

Our guests flipped out when they saw pie coming out, and I saw many people walking away at the end of the night with slices wrapped up to go. People came up to me to rave about the pie. People told me they will be visiting the shop next time they are in town. I'm not exaggerating when I say that the pie was a hit.

The pie and coffee here is delicious, obviously, but their customer service, care, and dedication is what makes them truly amazing. If you get the pleasure go here, please know you're getting something truly special. I also hope you get the chance to meet one of the nicest people I've ever met, Micah!

Thank you so much, Lancaster Pie...

The baker came out of the kitchen to thank us for buying the pie! These are THE BEST pies I have ever enjoyed. Lancaster Pies has a location on Prince Street and in the Lancaster Central Market.

from their website: They specialize in made-from-scratch sweet and savory pies with the same care and attention that would impress even your grandma. We don't cut corners here. Only slices. Starting as a pipe dream and a way to meet a baked-good blank space in our beloved city, LPC has become something of a local legend; despite being less than 3 years olde. A wee bit more than local, we have amazing people from all over the continent who go out of their way when visiting places like NYC to pick up one of our pies.

Are our pies really that good? You all butter believe it.

AND WE'RE PROUD OF WHAT WE DO We opened this shop with a couple of things in mind. First, we saw a gap in the pastry scene that our lead bakers were thrilled to fill. Our bakers have something of a magic touch when it comes to all butter crusts. Second, we want to treat others the way we want to be treated. That means honesty and integrity in our baking practices and how we treat everyone that walks through our...

My team and I spent some time at Lancaster Pies & Coffee as part of a celebration, if you will, of the team and the work they've been doing. We have been short-staffed for so long, so it was an acknowledgement, a thank you, for how they've continued to serve our guests so well in light of all we've been asked to do. I had told the owners this prior to our visit and they took it upon themselves to make our time there really special. They took such good care of us, asked about us, celebrated my team with us. And all that is above and beyond the phenomenal pies and drinks they serve. We tried many of their dessert pies that day - coconut cream, the bourbon pecan, apple and apple hand pies, chocolate peanut butter - all were phenomenal. I mean, phenomenal! As good as the pies were though, there is something about going to a place that treats you well, treats you kindly and seems to really appreciate you being there. Lancaster Pies & Coffee did just that. They are gracious, kind people and I'm so glad they are in our city....