McCall Jewelry Company — Attraction in McCall

I’m still blown away by our entire experience at McCall Jewelry. My girlfriend and I are very seriously talking about marriage and this was our ONLY experience looking at rings and stones that we actually enjoyed.

The sales staff were so lovely that I feel bad saying they’re in “sales.” We got offered help and advice if we wanted and were otherwise left alone with the jewelry to try on, look at, play with, and talk about with no overbearing feeling whatsoever.

We live in Boise but we found basically the perfect ring combination as a result of goofing around for half an hour in the store’s custom ring section. We aren’t local but I’ll absolutely make the drive back up if I ever need anything based off this one experience alone. Prices were extremely reasonable as well but I’d honestly pay inflated Boise prices just because of the experience we had in McCall.

Even outside of the rings for us as a couple - I’m an avid watch collector. McCall Jewelry was once again the ONLY place I’ve ever been able to handle and try on watches without witty sales remarks or other intrusions. I wholeheartedly believe this is the best place I’ve ever been to for either jewelry OR watches - let alone both in the same place.

I hope this review holds true and that my experience is consistent for everyone else who visits. It was such a breath...

I had a wonderful experience at McCall Jewelry. I originally entered as I was strolling through downtown but it turned into several trips back from Boise as Erica graciously and patiently went through a bunch of jewelry I inherited from my grandmother. I was sentimental about giving it up even though a lot was super unattractive. Erica and her husband talked me through my options and helped me decide what was best to keep, what we could trade in, and what to purchase in my grandmother's honor. I felt like they really cared about what was best for me, never about the sale. I was treated like a long time customer from the moment I walked in and I can't recommend them enough. Thank you,...

I was referred to McCall Jewelry Company with high exceptions based on the referral, not only did George meet my standards he exceeded them. George at McCall Jewelry company not only found an engagement ring for my now fiance, he had it sized and shipped to my house in Boise within a more than reasonable time. George also helped me with the financing of the ring. Thank you so much George. I recommend him and McCall Jewelry for all Jewelry desires. This shop has a wonderful small town feeling, and very inviting. Anyone in the Boise area needs to go to...