Cookies on Call — Local services in South Haven

We planned a trip to South Haven for my mother-in-laws birthday and needed a local bakery to make a cake to help us celebrate. I came across Cookies on Call and reached out to Abby to see if she could create a drip cake while we were visiting. I ordered ahead and arranged our pick up date for while in town. Showed up on our pick up date and Abby delivered a beautiful, delicious masterpiece! Everyone in our group loved it and we all raved it was one of the best cakes we’ve ever had. Working with Abby was a breeze and if we make it back to South Haven we will be sure to have something to celebrate just so we can get another cake from...

We were able to try some cookies, after having a hard time finding them. The website and Google info is out of date, they are no longer in Douglas, barely in Sagatuck, but it looks like the primary location is now in South Haven. We were able to find the cookies in the Butler Pantry in Sagatuck and picked up a half dozen cookies. My favorite was The Butler Pantry cookie with the chocolate chunk a close second. The sugar sugar cookie was very sugary, but not a traditional sugar cookie and the Turbinado sugar can get a slightly weird taste when in large quantities. Skip the chocolate and cherry and just get...

Fell in love with these cookies and biscotti while vacationing in Saugatuck! Doug at the Cookies on Call location at The Butler Pantry was fabulously knowledgeable about the products, and our family looked forward to seeing him each afternoon for our daily treats (and afternoon coffee - try the French Silk!). Every cookie was just delicious (kids loved chocolate chunk, hubby loved the Butler Pantry, and my fave was the Choc PB); and the Cherry Almond Pistachio biscotti was the best biscotti I’ve ever had in my life. I know what treats we’ll be sending family this year over the holidays! Can’t...