Angelo's StreetSide Pizzeria & Trattoria — Restaurant in New Providence

On family vacation at the Atlantis paradise island resort here in the Bahamas. The first or second day of vacation we usually like to order pizza because it is an easy dinner that we can get while settling in. Found this place right on the other side of the bridge from the resort! We are a family of 5 and ordered the antipasto salad, an XL “just cheese” pizza, an XL “all da meat” pizza with meatballs, sausage, and pepperoni, the cheesy bread, and a ham and cheese calzone. EVERYTHING WAS FANTASTIC!! The antipasto was soooo good and had plenty of salad and toppings for all of us. The crust on the pizzas was thin and crispy, the toppings were delicious. The cheesy bread was a must! Highly recommend to everyone. The ham and cheese calzone was so full of ham and cheese it was cooked perfectly. To say we enjoyed everything is an understatement! We will DEFINITELY order from here again the next time we come to the Bahamas!

One thing to note is that they are cash only! But they deliver to the island which is nice and when I was told they would be here at 6:30 they were...

This place was a great find from us Michiganders. Especially if you are staying at the Atlantis. They just opened about 10 months ago. Staff is super friendly. Pizza is hot and delicious. They have New York style thin crust pizza in addition to breadsticks, calzones and salads with cold drinks. We ordered two pizzas, 1 XL w/ green pepper and pepperoni and a small mushroom pizza. You can get flavored crust there too. They do have some specials there that they post or you can ask. The prices are very reasonable! We walked over the bridge from the Coral tower, which is about a 0.7 mile walk. There is a safe pathway to utilize for your journey. They let us eat inside which they have 3 colorful barrels that they used as tables. They have about 6 high chairs. They gave us plates, napkins and plastic silverware to use. I would highly recommend the walk to eat here. You can get it delivered. They said delivery fee is $7 ($2 bridge cost and $5 for delivery) which would be well worth if you didn’t want to make...

If this pizza place were a person, I’d marry it. And I’m pretty sure it would say yes, because these people are friendly, charming, and weirdly accommodating—like, “sure, we’ll put pineapple on only one-eighth of your pizza, toast the crust like a marshmallow, and cut it into hexagons” accommodating.

The pizza? Absolute perfection. Each bite is like a warm hug from an Italian nonna who loves carbs and doesn’t judge your life choices. Crust? Crispy, chewy, and low-key addictive. Sauce? So flavorful I’d drink it straight if that wasn’t frowned upon in public.

Also, shoutout to the staff—they’re the kind of people who smile at you like they mean it, not like they’re just waiting for their shift to end so they can go home and scream into a pillow.

Basically, this place is the Beyoncé of pizza joints: flawless, fabulous, and always delivering hits.

10/10 would sell my soul for...