Score Pizza — Restaurant in Niagara Falls

Food: 5 Stars Service: 5 Stars Ambience: 4 Stars Value: 5 Stars Sanitary: 4 Stars Overall: 4.6 Stars

First time here — and it won’t be the last!

We visited Score Pizza in Niagara for the first time, and from the moment we walked in, we were pleasantly surprised by how friendly and welcoming the staff were. Even though it was later in the evening, the team was full of energy, kind, and super patient as we took our time looking through the options. You could tell they genuinely cared about providing a great experience, no matter how late it was.

The overall vibe of the place immediately reminded me of Blaze Pizza back in Toronto — in the best way. The setup is very similar: you can build your own pizza from scratch, choosing your crust, sauce, cheese, and unlimited toppings. The menu and atmosphere both had that same laid-back, modern, customizable feel. If you’re a fan of Blaze, you’ll feel right at home here — but I have to say, Score might even have an edge!

We ordered two build-your-own pizzas, and watching them get made right in front of us was part of the fun. Everything looked fresh and high quality, and the staff took their time to make sure we got exactly what we wanted. The crust was thin, crispy, and cooked perfectly in their stone oven. The flavours were well-balanced, and each bite felt worth it — not overly greasy, just really satisfying.

Now let’s talk about the stuffed cheesy breadsticks — hands down the highlight of our visit. They were loaded with melty cheese, baked until golden, and incredibly flavourful without being too heavy. Honestly? I’d say they were even better than Blaze Pizza’s version. Super cheesy, perfectly seasoned, and ideal for sharing.

Another thing I appreciated: they’re open late, which is perfect if you're exploring Niagara and get hit with a late-night craving. It’s great to know there’s a place with quality food and a friendly team that doesn’t treat you like a bother just because it's past dinnertime.

Overall, Score Pizza nailed it on every level — from the warm service to the fresh ingredients and the relaxed, inviting atmosphere. It’s exactly the kind of local spot you’re happy to discover while travelling, and even happier to come back to the next time you're in town.

Would absolutely recommend to anyone visiting the area — especially if you love custom pizzas and cheesy bread done right. We’ll 100% be revisiting whenever we’re back in Niagara!

xx...

I really wanted to love this place. Walking in, I was immediately impressed—the facility is very clean and well laid out, with a modern, welcoming vibe. The prices weren't horrible either, especially for a tourist-heavy area like Niagara Falls. But what truly stood out was the staff: absolutely some of the friendliest people I've encountered. If I could give them 6 out of 5 stars, I would. They made the experience enjoyable even before we took a bite.

Unfortunately, the pizza itself was the biggest letdown. Simply put—it just wasn’t good. I’ve had better oven pizzas at home. The dough tasted low quality, almost like a frozen pizza you'd grab at a grocery store. The sauce was actually pretty decent and had some nice flavor, but the cheese was undercooked and stretchy in an unpleasant way. The pepperoni? Bland, cheap-tasting, and it didn’t crisp up at all. Overall, the pizza had almost no flavor aside from the sauce—it was just dull and disappointing.

We also tried the garlic bread, which was a noticeable step up from the pizza, but even that had its issues. The bottom was burnt, and sadly that charred taste overpowered everything else.

Maybe we just caught them on an off day, but based on this experience, I wouldn’t recommend Score Pizza in Niagara Falls. It reminded me a lot of Blaze Pizza in concept, but Blaze does it far better in every single way. Honestly, even Domino’s is cheaper and tastes better. Disappointing food, but stellar staff and a clean,...

Wow! We love pizza and while on vacation We had pizza in NYC n New Jersey and again at a different NYC place. But this in Niagara Falls, Ontario Canada was by far my favorite!!! The price was also VERY reasonable. We got to choose our own sauces, u limited toppings and cheeses and finishes and it is stone fired and fast! Everything is sooo fresh and good! All four of us chose different pizzas and all were yummy. Too big for me to eat the whole thing but they have boxes to take the rest home even if you say out in the sun to eat it here. The place is so cute and welcoming and clean. The staff is amazing! My pizza was white garlic sauce w Italian sausage n bacon n pepperoni n mushrooms and roasted garlic n red onions n green peppers and green olives n black olives n Asiago cheese n mozzarella n feta with an olive oil drizzle....