Legendairy Cookies 'N Creamery — Restaurant in Appleton

I could not have asked for a more incredible dessert for our September 2025 wedding! We chose the ice cream cookie sandwich bar and it was a huge hit with all of our guests (I mean, how could it not be?!). It wasn't only a dessert, but a fun experience for our guests to be able to create their perfect dessert!

Leading up to the event, communication with the owner was clear and seamless. We booked over a year and a half in advance and they were always quick to respond to any small questions that came up during that time making my planning process much easier.

On the day of the wedding, Legendairy showed up on time and prepared with all of the correct flavors we chose for our big day. They even brought along signage with the flavor options and cones for people who simply wanted a scoop of ice cream instead of a cookie sandwich! The Caramel Apple Crumble flavor was a HUGE hit!

The two gals working the cookie sandwich bar were so sweet and we heard wonderful things about them from our guests.

Extra perk - we got to take any extra cookies and ice cream home with us! Best believe I'll be having a scoop of ice cream every night until it's gone :)

There is nothing I would change about working with Legendairy for our wedding! It was truly the most iconic dessert (blows cake out of the water) and they were so easy to work with! Thank you for contributing to our...

After trying their delicious ice cream sandwiches from their food truck at an event last summer, my now husband and I decided to hire Legendairy Cookies 'N Creamery to cater dessert for our wedding, in place of a wedding cake. I have to say, we made the right decision! I was able to make all of the arrangements with Jeremy via email. We had a little bit of an issue with my bank linking to their online pay option, so I was able to easily pay by paper check. Jeremy worked with our venue prior to the wedding to make a plan for the evening and he and his staff arrived and were set up and ready to go with time to spare. They were so friendly and pleasant with our guests. Of course, the cookies and ice cream were outstanding! We have gotten so many compliments on how delicious the ice cream sandwiches were, how enjoyable it was to "build your own" dessert and how fun it was to have something a little different than cake. The variety of cookies, ice cream and toppings was really nice. I appreciated that there was an alternative topping to peanuts. As the bride, I didn't get to enjoy my ice cream as much as I wish I could have, but really, no worries, because we had leftovers! Jeremy was so wonderful to work with and he and his team really helped make our wedding...

I was dissapointed when I walked into the place and asked for a allergy guide one could not be provided.

Im sorry no shade on the staff they were friendly as well as the place is clean. However In today's day and Age you should at the very least have a guide with the top 10 Major Allergens in your food. Especially in a high traffic area Like down town.

I will not be returning nor can I recommend that other people do so until this is corrected.

Staff however was friendly and prompt. I was honestly quite dissapointed, and a little bit angry either way I had to walk out as I am not going to put myself at risk. However everything is made in house which is a good sign and very much appreciated. And makes it quite easy to create an allergy guide. Seriously please...