Donatello's — Restaurant in City of Niagara Falls

Very friendly atmosphere.(with Ninja turtle decor) You could tell it's a well known spot for locals. The counter guy knew a few people by name when they walked in and the phone orders were consistently coming in. It's not anything fancy, order at the counter(grab a menu and sit while you figure out what you want, then go back up to order), grab your own drinks from the cooler. They will bring your food to you when its ready and pay before you leave. Gentleman at the counter just made the experience better leaving me smile more than once. It's an old school New York style place. Glad I stumbled upon it and decided to stop before heading out of town after a weekend at the falls. The food was delicious. Wish I lived closer because I wanted to try more of the menu. It was a hard choice because it all sounded so good. Then after eating there, there so much more I want to try! I had the Greek wrap and my boyfriend had the Royal Hoagie. The only thing he regrets is not ordering the large because it was so good! The onion rings seemed to have their own batter on them which was slightly sweet but they were also phenomenal. Food came out quicker than I expected but we visted mid October, on a monday around 4:30pm, so the area wasn't very busy. Im sure the wait times during prime season might be longer but it would be worth the wait. It will most definitely be my first choice for food on my next vist...

My wife and I was visiting Niagara Falls last month from Spotsylvania, Virginia. One evening, we left our hotel to eat around 7:30 pm, we notice most of the surround restaurants were closing earlier than normal. After a few internet searches, we found a restaurant specializing in pizza called Donatello’s just 2 and half blocks from our hotel Quality Inn near Niagara Falls. Donatello’s is located on a quiet street up hill. Once, we arrived at Donatello’s, we notice it was a small family own restaurant. What a pleasant atmosphere. Once in Donatello’s the owner “Welcome” us with a warm smile and said sit everywhere you want. He said, his name was Donatello. He gives us a menu and told us about his dishes and specializes Pizzas, so I selected one of his pizzas with white cheese, onions, pepperoni and ham. I have living in country of Italy and eaten at some of the best Pizza Restaurants and Donatello’s create a perfect pizza, the crust being not thin or thick has a great taste. All the ingredients placed around the pizza, not just in the center, are baked in oven until perfectly done. Marvelous great Pizza! I can eat one every night. If you visiting Niagara Falls or just want a great pizza go to Donatello’s up the...

Great Pizza! We were staying in Niagara Falls for a couple days sightseeing with two kids. With COVID-19 going on selections on food were limited. The hotel restaurant was very expensive with an extremely long wait list, not to mention they are not kid friendly. We ordered a large extra cheese pizza and wings. Because we were staying in a hotel, the woman who took the call was more than happy to include napkins, paper plates and plastic utensils for us without hesitation for us. The ordered arrived in a timely manner. The food was hot and the pizza had loads of cheese on it! My fiancée' said the wings were excellent, which that in itself is a huge compliment because he is very picky about his wings. Being from Jersey, it's difficult to get pizza out of state. Donatello's food did not disappoint and neither did their service. The delivery driver was very courteous and professional. I wish they were closer to where I live, I would have a new pizza place! I highly recommend the food here. Good job Donatello's! Hopefully we'll see you again...