Turtle Town — Restaurant in Keystone

This place looks amazing, and I believe the coffee is supposed to be amazing too. However, three of us went there to get three coffees, and we had some questions about the cold/hot/flavor of the coffee. The place wasn’t much crowded but we didn’t take much time. The host had a nice smile, so we were talking nicely with her. She was almost done preparing the first coffee which was supposed to be cold. We ordered two cold coffees and one hot coffee. She got offended for some reason when we told her that. She was like “I know what I am doing” and was very rude to us since then. She almost banged the coffees on the counter. The first coffee was delicious, but the other two (iced mochas) were too bitter. Tip: Don’t ask he questions about their flavors, just order what you have...

I visited here last week on a trip. I bought 2 peanut clusters and piece of fudge. I was shocked this totaled $20, but paid anyway because I didn’t want to ask them to put things back. I was expecting this chocolate/candy to be amazing, but it is some of the worst I’ve ever had. The peanut clusters were horrible. I don’t know what they use, but it did not taste like chocolate at all. And the fudge was almost like they didn’t let the sugar fully dissolve, it was gritty and had a weird taste. Everything ended up in the garbage, $20 worth of candy. This place is ridiculously overpriced and the chocolate is awful. I do not...

Sample the fudge and candies before you buy! We missed this step and regret it...big time! Somehow we assumed (incorrectly) that all retail fudge shops in tourist towns would be similar if not identical recipes. Lesson learned. We took advantage of their buy 3 get 1 free. Bought chocolate, chocolate mint and grasshopper. All which were supposed to taste of chocolate...however if I were blindfolded I wouldn't taste even a hint of chocolate in any of them. Just sugar and mint (in those named such). Was a very busy place...mostly ice cream customers...probably can't go wrong...