Slice Shop — Restaurant in Naples

Being a native New Yorker, I can honestly say this is exactly what Naples, Florida, has been missing. Hands down, it’s the best slice shop in Naples and quite possibly the best pizza in Southwest Florida. Located right on Fifth Avenue South in downtown Naples, this spot brings true New York–style pizza to the heart of paradise.

Rob, the owner, is originally from Long Island and you can taste that authentic New York influence in every bite. He’s a complete gentleman, hardworking, and passionate about the craft. I was picking his brain because I know a little about the pizza game, and it’s clear he’s using the highest-quality ingredients — just the way great pizza should be made.

If you’re craving real New York pizza in Naples, this is the place to go. Crispy crust, fresh toppings, and that perfect foldable slice that reminds me of home. A must-try for anyone visiting or living in Naples who wants the best pizza experience on...

Slice Shop definitely has one of the better if not the best pizzas in all of Naples. I’ve been in a couple of times now & I like to try different slices each time. Not sure if it’s true but I heard you cannot order full pies which is a bit of a bummer. The other thing that I don’t like is how they seem to have an excessive amount of staff at the ordering area which causes an overwhelming customer experience and for the amount of people they have they seem to move slow. Lastly I’m not understanding the carnival ride style entrance where they let you advance to the ordering point when they feel it’s safe and clear. There was only 1 couple in front of us at the order point and I don’t see why we had to wait so long for them to be allowed to order. when there’s 10+ people standing behind the line who should be able to help...

This establishment owned by the very friendly Rob offers great authentic New York style pizza. Rob migrated to Naples from Queens NY. We tried a traditional New York slice, a margarita and also a square slice of honey soppressata. Everything was absolutely fabulous. We also ordered an eggplant Parmesan sandwich that comes with a salad, both incredible. Finally Rob, the owner asked us to try a pasta dish with a sage brown butter sauce, absolutely to die for. The staff at the ordering counter are a collection of younger individuals, well mannered, professional, and clearly motivated to serve a customer well. We highly recommend The...