Jerry's Pizza — Restaurant in New York

I think their pizza is okay if your getting a pie and it's fresh out the oven... I also see alot of people exaggerating their reviews a little with ALOT of bias Since they grew up in the area. It WAS the ONLY ONLYYY pizza place uptown on Boston road FOR A LONG TIME. People saying it's the best pizza have never gotten pizza from Staten island or anywhere else apparently. I've been living here since I was a kid and always loved Jerry's but Jerry In particular the owner just rubs me the wrong way sometimes I don't know if he doesn't like me or if he has some sort of direct problem with me but I would even suspect he's caught me walking the block with a box of domino's in my hand a couple of times and he doesnt like that lol. Well who cares all I can truly say is the pizza is great some days and ok somedays. He even gave me a free slice a couple times and the CALZONES are some of the best CALZONES in the Bronx if not THEE BEST CALZONES...

I grew up eating Jerry's Pizza for 25 years even though there was another pizza shop up the hill and Nick's pizza not to far from Jerry's. I moved out of state and have been gone for 21 years years. However, I visit home at least twice a year and I ALWAYS make Jerry's my 1st stop when I touch down and my last stop before I fly out. Most places change their menus, their ingredients, portions, prices and service. Not Jerry's!!! After all these years, the pizza, sicilians, pastas, calzones, beef pattys and hot subs still taste the same as they did when I was a child. Frank is still pleasant, sweet, kind and funny as heck. The service has remained top notch as always and the prices have not changed drastically after all these years. He's even kind enough and takes the time neatly wrap up and pack my to go orders for my 2 hour flight back home. This place and Frank has always been AWESOME. ...

I have been buying my pizza from Nick's Pizza on Gun Hill Road in my teen years. Years later, walking on Boston Road, and very hungry I decided to stop in Jerry's Pizza. I asked for slice, and told him, this pizza better taste as good as Nick's Pizza. He laughed, educated me that he knows it will be better, I was skeptical. I spoke with him, a very pleasant man and staff. The place was very tidy and clean. When I finished my slice I could not believe it, an excellent slice of pizza, I have never tasted pizza that good. I have told all my friends/family members. I had to tell him, this pizza is better than Nick's Pizza. All the places I have tasted pizza in the Bronx, this is the best to date. I would recommend anyone to try a slice. Thanks Jerry for Great...