Seaside Sweets — Restaurant in Tybee Island

Ice cream quality seems pretty good. However this ship suffers from multiple issues. Their Oreo shake is not consistent with any other shops definition of cookies and cream shakes. It is more accurately a cookies and cream icy. Which is fine, however misleading when labeled cookies and cream shake.

I personally very much enjoyed the bourvon Carmel flavor, I would recommend this flavor.

I was purchasing a large quantity of ice cream and I was not given a options of lids for the ice cream I ordered. This makes traveling with the ice cream particularly impossible. Add on that they do not carry a drink holder to make transporting multiple milk shakes easier

TL;DR they seem to do desserts well, however they seem to do everything else wrong. They mislabel their products, they do not carry the essentials when it comes to transporting their product. If you order and taste their ice creams and will be eating it right away, you will have a great experience here, however I can not igonre the massive inconvenience and short sightedness of their practice when giving them a little...

They must not give out free samples because they know how bad their ice cream tastes.

I was interested in the fudge brownie and asked what was in it. I was told fudge, chocolate ice cream and brownie pieces. It tasted like coffee. I had 2 other people try it to make sure I wasn’t crazy. My sister got the Cookie Monster which had an off taste to it…almost tasted like soap. We threw it away and did not eat anymore than what we tried.

The young man working was nice. We did not share with him our disappointment in the ice cream as I believe no refunds were available.

So I share this to 1) inform the owner; I strongly suggest you start offering samples and re-evaluate your flavoring.

And 2) to warn people to not waste your money here.

I am bummed that I am unable to recommend a local place over a chain. This time Ben and Jerry’s won. They got my money, a happy customer and a...

Please, PLEASE support this local business in this desperate time.

Not only do they have the best gelato I’ve ever had (we live a few hundred miles away) but their staff is so sweet and caring. We were down last weekend for a family emergency. Stress was high. I told my boyfriend we should go get a treat with our fresh air and we called ahead to be sure they were open. The girl was so polite and told us they were and offered the give us the flavor selection.

When we arrived, she was very polite, as well as very mindful of her actions to minimize germ spread.

If you want ice cream/gelato and are close, consider giving these wonderful folks your business. They can use all the...