Ozzie & Mae's 36 West Fourth — Restaurant in Williamsport

Even recognizing that Williamsport is a gastronomically challenged city and one must keep one's expectations low, this place was disappointing. We arrived at 6PM and were the first people in on a weeknight. As noted by others the atmosphere is unimpressive, but that's not all that unusual for a local Mexican restaurant. We started by ordering Margaritas. They arrived quickly but were insipid. Apparently little to no alcohol (and certainly no Triple Sec) and an overabundance of a sickly sweet yellow-green generic drink mix. The menu choices looked OK but when we started to order our waitress told us that they were out of shredded pork (which was featured in several dishes). So we asked about shredded beef (also featured in several dishes). They were out of that also. So attempting to be flexible, we decided to order the chicken Tamales. Oops, they were out of that also. Chili Rellenos? Out of those too. So we finally settled for a "Shepherd's Pie Chimichanga" (interesting concept but not particularly Mexican) and a Shredded Pork Chili Verde made with shredded chicken. The dishes when they came were acceptable but not exceptional. The chimichanga was wrapped in a flour tortilla and baked. The tortilla was, as might be expected, dried out and cardboard-like. The chicken chili verde was served with two flour tortillas (should have been served with corn tortillas) and was rather bland. Suffice it to say, we...

Other than Chi-Chi's, I can honestly say I don't recall ever eating Mexican. Ended up here because we went out with good friends and they picked.

I had no idea what to order so I went with something timid and mild, Sante Fe chicken. It was very good, not too spicy or anything. It was served with rice and veggies. Everything was great.

It was very nice inside, I only deducted 1 star for atmosphere due to being seated directly in front of the front door which opened directly outside to 20 degree air with folks coming in holding the door open. Definitely could use a vestibule if there was room.

All six people in our group enjoyed their food very much.

The tip was already included on our bill, so remember to check that when you pay.

We parked right next to the restaurant in "paid" parking lot, but a nice lady told me I didn't have to pay after 6pm, so I didn't and had no issues.

Good experience....

Delicious authentic Mexican food, always wonderful service, and very relaxed atmosphere. One of the owners always seen out on the serving floor politely checking in with customers - with a smile and a kind word. I have been coming to this restaurant since its inception (i2004 - if memory serves me right). It’s been really lovely to watch their business grow as well as their beautiful family! A wonderful and positive addition to the Williamsport community!! Keep it up! We’ll be back to the...