Sartù — Restaurant in Cortona

*Update - I made it to Cortona today, April 12, 2024, and I fulfilled my desire to visit Sartù and meet Michela in real life. The restaurant is down a magical little alley off of a picturesque Cortona street (you will only know the beauty of Cortona if you visit, so do yourself a favor and go!). It's just like the pictures, but better because it's right in front of you. The inside of the restaurant is cozy, with interesting artwork on the walls and decorative settings on the tables. Michela had a special greeting card just for me, knowing I was coming and enjoying my initial review. It was a nice and thoughtful touch and I knew right away that her passion was legitimate. Michela came out to greet me and my girlfriend with an authenticity and enthusiasm that warms the heart and makes you feel at home. We ordered antipasti, first & second courses, and of course dolci. Everything was amazing! The pasta was so fresh and delicious. The flavors were perfetto! The wines complimented the dishes completely. We were so happy to have such a great experience in so many ways. It really made our stay in Cortona extra special. Thank you so much, Michela, for the best time! ❤️ We will surely visit you again our next time in Tuscany. Until then, arrivederci!

I'm currently researching restaurants in Cortona for a trip in April, so I have not dined here...yet. I was first drawn in by the pictures of the entrance in the alleyway, which is enchanting. But my attention quickly turned to the responses to reviews from the apparent owner, Michela. They have become my entertainment for the evening. So passionate and raw, her scathing retorts are fierce poetry. The responses alone deserve 5 stars. I'm more intrigued than ever to visit this restaurant and meet this Michela. My only question is, does she offer...

Nestled in the heart of the picturesque town of Cortona in Tuscany, this restaurant is an absolute treasure waiting to be discovered. From the moment you step through its ancient doors, you are transported into a world where history and culinary excellence merge seamlessly. The ambiance is nothing short of enchanting. Housed within a beautifully preserved ancient building adorned with stunning frescoes, this restaurant exudes an air of sophistication and timeless elegance. But it's not just the ambiance that sets this restaurant apart; it's the exceptional food that truly steals the show. The menu is a carefully crafted masterpiece that pays homage to the rich culinary traditions of Tuscany. Every dish is a symphony of flavors, with ingredients sourced from local farms and markets to ensure the freshest and highest quality ingredients. Dining at this restaurant in Cortona is not just a meal; it's a memorable experience. From the enchanting ambiance to the exquisite food and impeccable service, every aspect of this dining establishment is a testament to the artistry of Tuscany. If you find yourself in Cortona, make sure to make a reservation and treat yourself to a culinary journey through time that you won't...

I don’t get why this restaurant is so highly rated, way overpriced for what you get. The idea is good but the experience is average, 35 mins wait for a cold starter, my Chianina steak was served stone cold and had to be reheated, then a grappa for €12. In spite of the chef’s insistence, we did not eat any dessert. We even found a bread chopping board on our seat… Is not that I want it cheap, I want it to be good! They simply think they’re better than what they are. The chef personally criticises the judgement of anyone that doesn’t leave a 5 star review.She’s been offending me since and even threatened to report us to the local authorities just for leaving a three star review. Don’t get fooled by their look (like I did!) keep walking and check on the other great, genuine and non crazy options in town.

Note: I gave this restaurant 3 stars based on my experience but changed it to 2 after reading the owners rude and...