Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Manteca, CA — Restaurant in California

This is upsetting! It' 3/16/25 and these are my experiences recorded. They had me fooled into believing thinking my bag contained the macaroni salad I ordered to side with the "Hang Loose" sandwich w/ Dutch Crunch Roll bread. This only came to my attention soon after opening my bag when I came home to Stockton 😨 To think that I should've walked in with more skeptism about the staff working there, indicating a clear sign of unprofessionalism. To have confidence in a business it starts with having good customer service/professionalism. I've had no negative experiences till now, so I walked in with the confidence of them fufilling my order. At around 4:15pm - 4:25pm, I came in to pick up the $4.49 Macoroni Salad and $20 sandwich. The woman working there had me believe the bag contained both items. Even after the fact that I signaled her using a gesture, "the go to box fingers", while I was asking about it. Rightfully so, I had recieved help from Grubhub support and initated a refund. Please do not have blind faith people and ward out for any incompetence in an establishment. If we cannot trust the service, then we have to check our orders every time we go to Mr Pickles at Manteca, CA. The sandwich was satisfactory, but unsatisfactory by defualt. I will probably not revisit...

The sandwiches here are great and easily the best in the area. I’ve been coming for years because nowhere else has good quality ingredients.

But damn, they’re expensive. For what you get, it’s basically a fancy snack. The portions are small, and if you go for the full sized meal deal, you’re easily dropping $20 to $30.

The staff? Always look like they hate being there. Grumpy, checked out, and they’ll forget little important things like the bacon on a turkey-bacon-avocado, hah, at least they never forget the cookie.

At the end of the day, if you’re craving a damn good sandwich and can stomach the overpriced, low effort vibe, it’s worth hitting up...

I came in during my lunch, deciding if I should go to In n Out or try something else. So I picked Mr. Pickles.. First time ever, and the service was pretty good. Tried out The Hero sandwich with Dutch bread, and added mustard onto it. Best sandwich I’ve had in a long time.

The girl who made it was sweet, and she did a really good job on making my food. I couldn’t get her name but I thank you regardless. The people working there had good attitudes at the time, and that made me come out of my shell to try something new. Keep up the good work guys, I appreciate you all....