Potbelly — Restaurant in Contiguous United States

First visit to this Potbelly Sandwich Shop and it’s tasty. Tonight we had a buy one get one coupon for Meatball subs ($9.39) so that is what we ordered. We also ordered a side of Vegetable Soup ($4.89) and we wanted a side of Chili-Mac ($6.59) but it only comes in a full bowl so that’s what we ordered. The Meatball Subs were tasty, but meatballs aren’t my favorite. I’ll order something different next time but this was pretty good. Tasty sauce, great bread, not messy. The Garden Vegetable soup was quite flavorful and we will order this again. The Chili-Mac is really tasty. I don’t know if I’ve ever had this anywhere else but that’s a hood choice for a meal right there. The staff is pretty good and the dining room is quite small with only 2 tables fir 4, 2 tables fir 2, and the rest is bar seating against the front window wall and then a couple of high tops along the side interior wall. This is a recommend to dine atPotbelly. It’s nice to have a different option to dine in the area other than the overload of McDonald’s, Wendy’s, Subways, Panera Breads that all seem to be mega-multiplied...

I had never even heard of this company until I drove past it. Third time I passed it I figured I had to stop and see what it was all about.

The ordering process seemed very much like other sandwich shops where you can specify what type of bread and toppings and continent you want for your sandwich. It was, however, a little more difficult to see your sandwich in fabricated, which was mildly uncomfortable.

First, know that I do not have finely tuned palate, but I really enjoyed my half Cuban sandwich and small chicken pot pie soup. When I was walking up, there was a big banana pudding shake sign, so I had to try that of course!

It was a little more expensive than I was anticipating, but he wouldn’t stop me from coming back

They get a theming nod by having a real potbelly stove in the shop and they get a sentimental star for featuring posters, souvenirs, and photos from the old local attraction Circus World! (Posner Park—including this shop—sits right on the old site of...

We stopped in for Sunday lunch on June 29, 2025, and let me tell you — this Potbelly did not disappoint. We’ve been here before, but this time we grabbed food for the whole crew. Steve went classic with the Smoked Ham, Dad stuck with his tried-and-true Italian, Mom had the mac and cheese (because of course she did), and I went straight for the Prime Rib Steak — because beef wins brunch.

Every sandwich was hot, flavorful, and exactly what we ordered. No mystery ingredients or soggy bread in sight. The roasted garlic aioli on mine was chef’s kiss, and Steve said his sandwich was “better than it had any right to be.” That's high praise from a guy adjusting to new eating rules.

Service was fast and the staff didn’t flinch at our order of six random things — including chips, a Crush soda, and a "no spoon, no napkin" mac cup. 😂 It’s the little things.

Potbelly just gets it. Solid food, no stress, and enough comfort to count as a...