Supremo Pizza — Restaurant in Midvale

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THIS TRASH! After living less than a quarter mile away for almost 3 years, I understand why I haven't heard of this place until recently. This past Friday I tried a couple different pizzas from here and they were great. The bianci and 3 cheese with pepperoni was perfect! Tonight I thought pizza and a movie would be a good plan, but the pizza was the temu version of what I had the night before. With his order, they skimped the cheese (on a 3 cheese...), the peppers were undercooked/crunchy and the meatballs tasted like steakums. Update: nobody has reached out or offered to make it right. The owners must be perfectly alright sending out poor quality food all day because they OBVIOUSLY don't give a flying furry duck about whether people actually enjoy the food they overpaid for. Skip the drama and grab a red baron. Same quality, but...

We have been on the search for the perfect thin crust pizza with those crispy little pepperonis, (you know the ones), and our search has come to an end! Supremo serves up amazing New York-style pizza. Honestly the most authentic we’ve found in Utah. We’ve tried the pepperoni, five cheese (personal fave), buffalo, and BBQ chicken — all were delicious.

The flavors are spot on, though the buffalo pizza had a bit more sauce than we expected. We took home the leftovers and threw it in the air fryer the next day and it was even better the second round. 😂 Definitely a go-to spot for quality pizza!

⭐️Food: 10/10 ⭐️Service: Great ⭐️Atmosphere: Small, clean space. Parking can be a bit tricky while events are going on next door. ⭐️Value: Definitely worth driving up to for a late night slice. Pizza always comes out HOT and you can conveniently order ahead...

In honor of Bitcoin Pizza Day, I decided to pick up a couple pizzas—and what a delightful surprise it turned out to be. Their menu offers unbeatable value. The prices were incredibly reasonable, especially considering the generous size of the 18" pizzas. The Hawaiian pizza was a standout. The pineapple was sliced thinly, avoiding the usual watery chunks, and baked to perfection. The classic cheese pizza was equally impressive. The crust was light with a slight crisp, and the undercarriage was pure perfection—golden and evenly browned. Supremo Pizza is a bit of a hidden gem—a small, unassuming spot with minimal signage. Despite its modest appearance, the quality of the food speaks volumes. It’s a must-try for anyone in the area looking for authentic, flavorful pizza.

Happy...