The Bagel Market — Restaurant in New York

It’s unfortunate to give this place 1 star because the food is great and the employees are very nice, but they get your order wrong almost every time. We’ve been coming here pretty often for over 2 years still trying to give them a chance because we love their bagels, but more times than not our orders are wrong. I’d say around 80% of the time our orders are wrong. They just won’t write anything down, it’s ridiculous. I ordered a whole wheat everything bagel and went back to the store after I saw it was wrong, and they straight up tried to convince me this was whole wheat. It’s not, clearly it’s regular per the picture. They insisted it was whole wheat but just a “lighter color today”. What??? Insanity. We pay for add ons to breakfast sandwiches like avocado and it’s missing. Waste of money and extremely frustrating because it’s been consistently happening for years. Updating this review because we just ordered bacon egg and cheeses and they forgot the bacon, didn’t melt the cheese and absolutely drowned it in hot sauce. It is inedible. Like so many of their egg sandwiches because they make them horribly and/or always forget your order - it’s inedible there. Such a waste of money because it’s expensive. Never...

I love this place. Pretty much anytime I'm working in the neighborhood I pop by for breakfast or lunch. No complaints on the bagels, accompaniments, portions, or price.

My go-to lunch is the Bird Sandwich which comes with turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo. I like to get it on a toasted California bagel (I think they invented this type of bagel; it basically has a bunch of grains and oats in it and is a tinge sweet). All the sandwiches come with a bag of chips and a pickle, so it's quite a satisfying meal!

I'm also a big fan of their lox + plain cream cheese, which I like to enjoy sandwiched between a toasted sesame bagel.

They have like 15 other varieties of bagels and cream cheese, so whatever you fancy they probably have it.

If you're not in the mood for a bagel, you can also get sandwiches on sliced bread or rolls. You can even do a salad. They also have an impressive display of baked goods, packaged treats, and beverages for your snacking pleasure.

It can get a little busy during the breakfast and lunch rush, but the guys are fast so don't let the lines...

A regular stop over after being in the park with my dog - order a bagel and coffee, and tip the counter workers . Today, with my hands full of flowers to plant from the Framers Market, could only order/ carry a bagel, when I attempted to pay with my debit, since it was under $5.00, the counter worker said I couldn’t pay for the bagel that way - and then stared me down as if I had committed a crime of some sorts. Left without my bagel, feeling violated. They obviously only cater towards their seamless/grub hub/Yelp clientele. Bring your business to Bagel World on fifth, better bagels/w counter- workers who see you...