Your Pie Pizza — Restaurant in Orlando

Updated : They are back ! I’m glad. This is such a good alternative from other fast food/ restaurants in the area some nights. Staff and service was great the night I went. Very helpful & professional. The location was clean and just as I remember prior to their closing ! I believe they are under new management now. Gluten free dough option is pricey ($4.50) but that would be the only complaint.

Pictures attached of Menu and more !! This place is clean, spacious, and modern. Pricing is good! Pizza is on the smaller side 10" but its satisfying. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. They really made us feel comfortable and welcomed with it being our first time. Menu is in large wall print. Kids size option (pizza, panini, salad). Unlimited toppings, they recommend only 5 because of the pizzas size. A variety of veggie and meat toppings. Oven finished pies are enough to fill one person. Gelatos are Delicious (cookie n creme, and strawberry/chocloate). I am not a Gelato fan but will be returning for the pizza, cookies n creme gelato, and the experience. Timothee was very helpful and friendly, he even gave some "your pie" background. Genius idea- they have a little sink near the beverages for quick hand washes.

The ONLY flaw, if I had to name any, would be that the wall menu and line are too close, making it a bit difficult to properly see all the awesome options. They do have menus in a holder as well. Still this place is 5 star worthy. Their wheat crust is a great selection and they have a fire oven, try em out!!!! Cooked to a crisp but not burnt is...

I was so excited to hear that a Your Pie was opening nearby! We used to order from a location that ended up closing and were bummed because we liked it so much, so we couldn’t wait to go get our fix at this new location!

Your Pie is all about customization. You can order a 10” pizza, a panini, a salad, or pasta and have it anyway you want. I like that there’s just one base price and then you can go nuts. They have a few recipes you can choose from if you don’t want to create your own also. On this visit, my boyfriend and I both opted for a pizza. He chose the Great White since he loves their white pizza. I did a pie with a mixture of marinara and pesto sauce, fresh AND shredded mozzarella because why not, feta, mushrooms, black olives, basil, and chicken. The person assembling our pies was super nice as was the cashier. We paid and found a table. After a short wait, our pizzas were brought out.

I was very happy with my creation. The ingredients tasted fresh and the crust has a nice, light char on it that gives it a great flavor. My boyfriend was happy to have the Great White back in his life. This place also serves gelato which looks yummy, but I couldn’t quite finish my pizza so I didn’t partake this time. I like that they have to go boxes right near the area where you drop off your plates so it was easy to pack up my leftovers.

Chains sometimes sacrifice quality for convenience, but Your Pie definitely has both covered in my opinion. I can’'t wait to return for my next pizza craving and come up with a new...

Lots of great reviews so we decided to give this place a try. Maybe it is just that today is Easter, but I was not impressed with the "fresh" ingredients at all. I am used to a place like this called Mod Pizza. Lots of options, mostly fresh. But, we pressed on.

My boyfriend got the lineage supreme and I did a build my own gf pizza. For the celiacs out there, they have someone come out and make your pizza specifically to avoid cross contamination, but the only sauce I was offered was marinara. 😕 I don't generally eat red sauce on pizza, but this wasn't too bad.

The staff was friendly enough, but the girl making my pizza was very stingy with all the ingredients, save for the🫑. 🤷🏻‍♀️ After putting on 3 or 4 leaves of spinach, she asked if there would be anything else. 🤔 Well, I'm not going to eat a 3 leaf spinach pie, thank you so, yeah, let's be daring and try adding some more toppings. 🙄 OMG after every single topping she asked. Every... single ... topping. 😐 Hopefully you can see in the pictures, it's not like she gave me much.

P ate all of his pizza, and some of mine. He said his was definitely better than mine. Mine was ok. The crust could stand to be cooked a little longer (a bit doughy), but, I've had worse.

Peter had an IPA but I forgot to take a picture of it. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Edible food, but not worth the raving reviews. At least not during our visit. Bottom line, it's a decent meal, but not one worth a revisit from us.

If you like honest, detailed reviews, follow...