Fire Engine Pizza Company — Restaurant in Put-in-Bay Township

Not the Same Quality — Bad Experience the Second Time

We ordered the exact same thing yesterday and today — two large pizzas, one pepperoni and the other half pepperoni, half bacon. Yesterday’s pizza was decent, and the kids actually enjoyed it enough to want it again today, even though I wanted to try a different restaurant.

Unfortunately, today’s pizza was a whole different story — and not in a good way. Within hours, our entire family ended up with stomach issues. Everyone had to use the restroom multiple times (3–4 times each), and that’s just not normal. I could tell something was off just by looking at the pizza: the crust didn’t look or feel right, and if you’re a true pizza lover, you know what I mean — when the pizza appearing is just off, you can tell right away.

Also, the outdoor seating area isn’t enjoyable if you’re not drinking. Most of the people there seem to just hang out for alcohol, and the food feels like an afterthought. I’m honestly tired of the fake hype some of these places push just because it’s on Put-in-Bay. It’s like they’re trying too hard to be some version of Key West, Florida — but it’s not.

We won’t be back. Disappointed that the quality wasn’t consistent and even more upset that it made our whole family sick. That should never...

Excellent pizza! Would definitely come back to get more pizza from Fire Engine Pizza Company. The gentleman that made our pizza today was friendly and he made us an AMAZING pizza! It was so good! When we were walking back from the park after eating our pizza, I stopped back into Fire Engine Pizza Company just to say THANKS for the great pizza! Excellent location, super friendly staff and overall, some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I would 100% recommend Fire Engine Pizza Company to friends and family. Keep up the great work and the excellent pizzas Fire Engine Pizza Company! We will definitely come back and try a different...

My wife and I stayed on the island for the first time with friends that have been there before. They recommended the pizza. Wow I truly have never had a pizza with so many toppings. We had it Monday night and the manager said the next day Tuesday. All the pizzas were half price. so my wife and I got another pizza to split. Thanks for the best pizza we have had. 😁👍🇨🇦 I’m editing this review because I just checked my credit card and the guy added a $5.00 tip to my bill. Don’t use...