Sara's Bakery - featuring Tipsy Pies — Restaurant in Stillwater

We had Sara's Tipsy Pies cater our wedding and we got so many compliments!! Firstly, just a warning, if you do a wedding tasting with her, you do have to pay $50 on her online website (which makes sense, since you are eating her food) but you get SO MANY SAMPLES. And whatever you don't finish you get to take home with you! Since we originally hired her, she's added bundt cakes (a million times yes, get these, the lemon ones are my favorite) and donuts and a few other things - all delicious.

Sara was so nice to work with and was willing to adjust numbers and options when I discovered the new items she added to her menu. She has various shapes too, so we were able to make the vegan irish apple pie a heart (so it was clearly different and stood out for the vegans) and my favorite flavor, the blueberry, the shape of MN which was so fun! Not only does she caterer to vegans, but she also has gluten free options as well! (These went so fast at our wedding) All her pies are the perfect size for not sharing without feeling like you ate too much and the booze keeps everything moist but is clearly baked out so it's safe for kids/isn't really alcoholic.

The pricing is very fair for what you get and Sara is so sweet. She gave us a separate box with samples of all the goodies knowing that we'd be too busy on our day to seek out food and flavors and this way we got some put aside just for us to enjoy the following day while we were recovering. Also the "cutting" pie is the perfect size for sharing and you get another one on your one year anniversary! We got a custom cake topper for our wedding pie and she was so helpful in trying to help us figure out the dimensions.

Every treat ended up being individually boxed to keep everyone safe with COVID going on, and it worked out super well because we had a ton of food for our meal, so people got to take these pies home as a sort of favor as well. The snickerdoodle cookies (also a hidden gem) were also individually bagged and made good treats for later in the night.

Sara's been so great to work with and I definitely suggest stopping at her physical location as well. It's a cute coffee shop in Stillwater, and a coffee and one of her pies make the best walking companion when you are strolling the streets downtown. Highly recommend for catering or...

For those if you looking for a hidden gem, this store is it! Making super cute, unique pies and baked goods fresh for you and your special events. That's right, people have these pies at their wedding receptions, grad parties, family reunions and more! I loved physically going to the store because it's nice to shop again and see people's faces. I brought my friends because I had bragged about how tasty the pies were and they ended up leaving with super cute handmade clay mugs, aprons, kitchen goodies, and sweet treats. I like that they support other local homemade producers and gift supplies, because that's what makes the world go round! Leanne is a wonderful pie baker and we love her 😍 Sara's staff are so friendly, helpful and really love to help make people's days sweeter. Oh! They also have coffee LITTERALLY from one of their friend's family farms in Costa Rica. Talk about straight from the source! They have Costa Rican creamer, too (😱🤩🤩🤩🤩😱 so good!!!). 10/10 recommend. Hot pies. Frozen pies to go. Goodies. Artisan Coffee. What more can you ask...

We’d just dined at Perkins and my partner was disappointed because he had his mind on a piece of pecan pie. Perkins only has them at holiday time. We had a bike repair at Chilkoot & noticed the Tipsy Pie sign, so I checked if they had Pecan Pie! Why yes they did! Not in the fresh case but frozen. Take & bake at home! They really hit the mark with both gluten free & traditional crusts! I purchased both and a boozy blueberry as well! We’ve just baked them in a camping trip in our RV! Soooo good! We love a boozy desert and these do not disappoint! Flakey crust and beautifully balanced flavors! One thing that made us chuckle was the staff person who waited on us… he had the hiccups! We joked afterwards that perhaps he’d been sampling too many Tipsy Pies! 🤣 Highly recommend & we will make a special trip for these delicious...