Montauk Market Café and Deli — Restaurant in Town of East Hampton

My visit to Montauk Market left me utterly disappointed and frustrated. I ordered their 'avocado toast,' only to discover an egg on top, triggering my severe allergy. When I returned to have it remade, I was appalled to find a clerk carrying a dog in the kitchen—an unacceptable practice for food safety.

Despite explaining my allergy and discomfort with their handling of pets near food preparation areas, the clerk adamantly refused a refund, insisting I should have known about the egg. This refusal was coupled with an attempt to charge me for hot water, a basic service I expected to complement my purchased tea.

The confrontational attitude and the disregard for customer safety and satisfaction were unsettling. As a person of color, I couldn't shake the feeling that prejudice may have influenced their treatment.

I implore anyone considering Montauk Market to reconsider. The lack of regard for allergies, food safety, and customer respect is disheartening. Avoid this establishment if you value proper food handling and a welcoming...

Worst thing I’ve ever eaten. The old place near Gosmans was always good. I spent $33 on two wraps and a bottle of water today. My chicken salad sandwich taste as if it turned. Staff seemed confused when I came in to pick up. People behind the counter wearing shirts that display other restaurants. Very unprofessional, expensive and poor quality. I will never go back there. I’m sure they will be out of business before long. Owner should probably spend a little time in there instead of leaving kids to run their lively hood. I’ve been in service industry a long...

If you're looking for quality and taste, this is your place. Breakfast sandwiches and wraps are all on point, paired them with fresh smoothies that are all fruit no ice, its perfect! We called ahead for breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches, they offered to saran wrap to keep them fresh in cooler, we filled the cooler with ice and loads of drinks, all in one stop. My favorite...