Shagwong
Shagwong things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay

Affordable Hotels in Town of East Hampton
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Town of East Hampton
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
Posts
My husband and I came in with my task-trained service animal (I have Tourette’s syndrome). We didn’t know that the owner was not keen on animals. The gentleman who greeted us was quite reluctant to seat us and said that the owner, Jason does not permit animals inside. I explained that, per the ADA law, service animals cannot be denied. It was clear that the host was really grappling with letting us stay and I tried not to be a “Karen” about it. After some consternation, we were sat in a corner and my service dog curled up quietly under the table, where she stayed for the next 90min. Initially we waited to get a drink order but a young woman finally came by and was lovely and cheerful. She offered my service dog a cup of water. I ordered a Guinness, my husband ordered an IPA. We waited a little bit and a very handsome and kind young man delivered our drinks (I now know that is Eoghan.) he asked if we were ready and we were not. The young woman came by a bit later and we ordered a dozen raw oysters, the prime rib sandwich and a cheese burger medium rare. I should have specified to have the oysters come first. When the food runner brought out the oysters and the prime rib sandwich he did not mention at all that my burger was on the way. He just sort of drop the two items and then walked away. The first oyster I went to enjoy was just a shell no oyster in it so I did a quick inventory and learned that three of the twelve oysters were just a shell. Eoghan was able to get us the missing oysters replaced quickly. But no luck with the burger I was waiting for. And then, finally it arrived! It looked so pretty! I got the zucchini fries and they were so delicious. Sadly, my medium rare burger was legit well done. It was extra disappointing because the cheese looked so good the bacon was crispy and the lettuce/tomato was super fresh! I had about 2 bites only. I decided to drown my sorrows and when I next saw Eoghan I got a Jameson neat. It’s a $17 glass of whiskey. It helped ease my pain, lol. The busser/food runner asked if I would like a box for the cheeseburger and I said no thank you, I could not eat it because it was way overcooked. He just smiled. I was hoping he would ask if I wanted to see manager or have it redone but I did not bring it up. We got the check from Eoghan who delivered it with speed and alacrity. We were charged twice for the oysters but it was promptly removed from the bill. Then the check just sat on the table with our credit card on top. I saw FOH staff walk by and look at it and just ignore it. Finally someone grabbed it. It was $176. We gave Eoghan $40 cash tip.
Leya TopodasLeya Topodas
00
04/27/24 evening Food and service outstanding. 04/29/24 Food and service was less than 1 star. Bottom line, if I did not patronize this establishment after my first visit, they would have 5 stars. On the 27th, Shagwong was body to body packed, service was on time, food was plentiful, drinks kept coming, and 100 percent satisfaction with fish and chips and fried zucchini. 4/29/24, early evening, 1 waitor, only 2 tables being served, only 4 patrons at the bar, service was so below par, food was horrible, tiny portions, and black male waitor shrugged and said he was busy? Busy doing what??? The avocado fish tacos were cold, only had a tiny pinky finger size piece of avocado and had more chopped veggies than fish. Never will recommend this place to anyone.
AngelinaAngelina
00
This is one of the only places we could find in town that was open during this time of the season. When you walk in it’s a small bar and to the right they have a dinning area. Very cool pub like vibes. Ali took great care of us. She was very nice and attentive. The food was very yummy. The clam chowder was a nice change to what my normal liking is. I was impressed with it. The French fries and sweet potato fries were some of the best I’ve ever had in any restaurant. The crab cakes were nicely made not overdone with breading. We had chicken fingers and fish and chips. I suggest giving the fried food here a try. It’s very good.
Kelli HogwoodKelli Hogwood
00
The energy in the place was simply amazing, creating a vibrant and inviting atmosphere that instantly made me feel at home. The food at this restaurant is truly impressive. While I thoroughly enjoyed my visit, I did find the burger to be a tad salty. However, its delicious flavor more than made up for it, and it was still a delight to savor. Chowder was so delicious 😋. One of the standout features of this establishment is the fantastic staff. The people who work here are incredibly friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. They go above and beyond to ensure that every guest feels welcomed and well taken care of.
Goran NYC PhotographerGoran NYC Photographer
00
Nearby Attractions Of Shagwong
IGA - Montauk
Kirk Park Beach
Montauk Blue Hotel
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
Marram
Daunt's Albatross Motel
Hero Beach Club
The Montauk Beach House
Ocean Surf Resort
Ocean Resort Inn

IGA - Montauk
4.1
(236)Click for details

Kirk Park Beach
4.6
(208)Click for details

Montauk Blue Hotel
4.4
(207)Click for details

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
3.9
(278)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Shagwong
Harvest on Fort Pond
John's Pancake House
668 The Gig Shack
The Point Bar & Grill
Anthony's Pancake House
John's Drive-In
Montauk Bake Shoppe
Muse @ The End
Joni's
Tauk at Trail's End

Harvest on Fort Pond
4.5
(494)Click for details

John's Pancake House
3.9
(413)Click for details

668 The Gig Shack
4.5
(349)$$
Click for details

The Point Bar & Grill
4.3
(363)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
774 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954
Map
Phone
(631) 668-3050
Call
Website
shagwongtavern.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.1
(415 reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Fresh seafood & American comfort fare plus cocktails make this traditional tavern a local mainstay.
attractions: IGA - Montauk, Kirk Park Beach, Montauk Blue Hotel, Royal Atlantic Beach Resort, Marram, Daunt's Albatross Motel, Hero Beach Club, The Montauk Beach House, Ocean Surf Resort, Ocean Resort Inn, restaurants: Harvest on Fort Pond, John's Pancake House, 668 The Gig Shack, The Point Bar & Grill, Anthony's Pancake House, John's Drive-In, Montauk Bake Shoppe, Muse @ The End, Joni's, Tauk at Trail's End
