Nicoletta Pizzeria — Restaurant in Washington

Staff are excellent & the location is tough to beat, but what matters is the pizza...

While their new pizza is better than their pizza of pre-2023, it's still just not that great compared to other options in the neighborhood. The crust is good, and the toppings are excellent but they're too spartan; without the toppings things taste a bit bland. But it feels like they're continuing to refine their recipes, so I'm hopeful things will only get better.

As of Spring 2023 the non-pizza menu is still unavailable, which is unfortunate since their hoagies used to be pretty good & pretty much the only such options...

I ended not eating there due to the lack of customer service. They had a pepperoni pizza with jalapeños on it. My 11 year old asked for a plain pepperoni pizza. Without anyone in line the manager refused to add pepperoni to the cheese or cook a new one without jalapeños. He did offer to remove jalapeños from a precooked pizza. Doubt he’s ever tasted a pizza that has something removed and believes the...

I won’t be back. They added 20% gratuity to pizza by the slice. When I said no thanks, the cashier was furious, dropping the F bomb. No thanks. I went to a restaurant next door and happily paid 20% for pleasant service. I will say the waterfront is wonderful, overwhelmingly people are friendly, and most restaurants are delicious. The view is...