If you’re craving real New York–style pizza, this place absolutely nails it. The crust is thin, perfectly crunchy on the edges, and foldable just like a true NYC slice should be. The sauce has that perfect balance — rich, tangy, and slightly sweet — and it complements the fresh, gooey cheese beautifully.
The staff here are super friendly and fast, making the whole experience even better. You can tell they care about both their food and their customers. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a whole pie, everything comes out hot, fresh, and delicious.
Honestly, one of the best pizza spots I’ve found — feels like a little slice of New York right here! 🍕🙌
Ps. It was too good I had to dig in before...
Read moreWhen you’re in the heart of old town Scottsdale it’s easy to walk right past some of the best food joints, and Old Town Pizza is definitely one of those that took some whispers through the grape vine to finally come around and try & it did not disappoint. To begin ambiance is clean and vibrant, with minimalist decor which makes it very approachable. Pizza of course was incredible, and my favorite was the sweet heat, balancing out the pineapple with jalapeño is a perfect combo. Service was good, but nothing above and beyond here but they definitely were friendly. Overall good experience, & will now be the first pizza joint I’ll recommend to friends for...
Read moreIt’s refreshing to get pizza from someone who understands what pizza is supposed to be: straightforward, flavorful, and filling.
I always make sure to try a plain cheese slice from a new place, that way you get a good idea of the quality of the sauce and dough. Did not disappoint.
I also tried the honey hot and the pepperoni, fantastic. The pepperoni is nice and crispy as it should be. Big ol’ slices, perfect balance of cheese and sauce.
Brought a pie for my crew to try, and it vanished like magic. Stop by, you’ll be...
Read more