Jacob & Anthony's American Grille — Restaurant in City of Saratoga Springs

Overpriced. I know what a good steak is worth - this was not a good steak.

I had the Caesar salad to start - the small size was generous. It was a very standard Caesar salad but some of the romaine pieces had turned brown, which should be unacceptable in a higher end dining establishment.

I had the 8 oz filet which I asked to be cooked rare. The first thing I noticed when the meat came out was that it had a visceral smell to it - like it had been cooked with liver. Pretty scary. The meat was cooked medium well, not rare. The Menu indicated the steak would be a accompanied by mashed potatoes and onion straws. What came out was what appeared to be French’s fried onions mixed into the mashed potatoes like a four-year-old might concoct. The mashed potatoes were tasty and seemed like they would’ve been great on their own but the option wasn’t there because it came out pre-mixed with the fried onion bits.

And hindsight I should have complained and returned the meat. Unfortunately I was a little pressed for time and hungry. I took half of the meal home but will not finish it.

The wines by the glass list is pretty good. The bartending staff is friendly and attentive. But the above meal with two glasses of wine was literally $100 with tip Absolutely not worth it. I have no problem spending good money on great food so won’t be going back here.

Interestingly enough if you use Yelp to find steak houses in Saratoga Springs this one does not...

I looked at Jacob and Anthony’s menu on February 1st online and made reservations for Valentine’s Day weekend with the impression that their menu prices were true and cheaper than the other places in saratoga. I call back on February 10th to confirm I still have reservations and I take another gander at their online menu… I find out that they JACKED up all their prices for Valentine’s Day weekend to $70 a steak and all other menu items. If I knew that in the first place then I would have made a reservation to a fancier place and somewhere like 15 church or mouzon house. But now I can’t get reservations to them places because it is too late. Needless to say I am UPSET and might not even show up when the time comes. NOT COOL!

Ok so our first experience was HORRIBLE. Waited for the food for an hour. The people next to us walked out. The food sucked and was cold. I had to get up and walk around to find the manager and finally told him about our bad food. He didn’t have the guts to come to the table so he sent a server. Not good & never again. Don’t...

Wasn't impressed. I ordered eggplant stack appetizer and it was awful. Nothing unique here. Slice of Panko breaded eggplant with a slice of zucchini, a blob of thick tomato sauce, motz cheese. That's it. Big deal. No imagination. You get 3. I ordered the pear & walnut salad for dinner, ordered large. Dissapointed as well. It tasted dry, no dressing for the first half, about 4 pear " sticks " and a few walnuts. As I was eating it they either forgot it was a large salad and dumped it upside down in a bigger bowl....or the made it upside down, dressing first, then a pile of Shaved carrots, then the mixed greens on top of that. It was weird. For a Saturday night in Saratoga during racing season it wasn't busy. I was there 6pm - 9pm. Once you get a look at the menu prices you'll know why. $67 for a ribeye. My salad was $19 ! Place looked fairly new inside but it was cheaply decorated, except for the horse portraits in the private room.+1 Restrooms clean and actual rooms instead of " stalls " +1 First time and last time...