Your Pie Pizza — Restaurant in Columbus

Casual pizza spot where you can build a pizza to your liking or choose one of their specials. It checks all the boxes for me! There are tons of ingredients to choose from (including vegan cheese) and toppings are unlimited - even if you start with one of the menu pizzas, you can make as many changes as you want. Lots of room to get creative. They also have a range of sizes: the 7” and 10” pizzas are both suitable for one person depending on your appetite, and the bigger size would be good for sharing. It’s not the cheap greasy type of pizza, so depending on the ingredients you choose, you can create something relatively healthy. There’s also pasta and salad on offer, which I did not try. For dessert, they have a modest gelato selection too (6-8 flavours if I remember correctly, mostly pretty standard stuff with a few specials), which also seems pretty high quality. Decent beer selection with the basics plus a few craft beers. First visit (2023): Tried the Kickin’ BBQ Peach Pizza, a summer special menu item, and got rid of the bacon, added peppadew peppers and basil. It was really good! I love the pairing of fruity and spicy so the flavours were right on the mark for me. I might leave off the peppadew peppers if I were to redo my order just to keep things simple since the ingredients that came with the pizza were already really flavourful, but they were still a tasty addition. I had a scoop of peaches & cream gelato for dessert. Very creamy, with swirls of real peach compote. Second visit (2024): Same quality as last year. I did a custom order with a buffalo sauce base, vegan cheese, and some veggie toppings. The vegan cheese is standard stuff, same as you can buy at the grocery store; slightly gooier than real cheese but works fine. My pizza came out delicious. The service is pretty fast for food made to order. The staff were friendly and seemed eager to help customers customize their pizza, so I didn’t feel like I was a bother for...

Typically I’d leave a 5 star review because the food is good and the service isn’t bad. Today I’m not, today my wife was fully embarrassed to the point of tears in there by a female worker who was the “supervisor on shift”. My wife has recently got a puppy to be a service dog. The puppy is very tiny, because it’s a small breed dog. She is in training and goes everywhere with my wife. The girl yelled at my wife for having her and acting like the dog was contaminating the food. Despite a barricade and glass protecting the food. She was let known she is a service animal in training. She doesn’t have a vest yet, again she is a very small dog not even the size of a forearm and has to have a custom ordered vest. She is only 11 weeks old. She doesn’t walk with her she is held the entire time. After my wife pays for the food and is now crying she goes to sit in her car. The guy who rang her out came and asked if she was okay. Then the girl who yelled at her came out with the food and coupons trying to apologize and bribe my wife. Saying she couldn’t imagine how she made her feel and that she has a service animal herself. I could understand if she brought in an unruly dog that is clearly not a service animal but she didn’t. She brought in a small dog who was just laying in her arms being calm like she is being trained to do in social situations...

The food was great. We’re from Pennsylvania visiting family and this is one of the spots we were really excited to come to again. Our first experience was amazing. This time…not the same. There was one female working with long curly dark hair, glasses and about 5ft tall. When I ordered my food, I had asked that she not put 3 ingredients on one of their signature pizzas. She gave me tons of attitude with my request. Then I had asked that she make my wings extra crispy….she closed her eyes at me…paused for a solid 5 seconds and then said “sure” and rolled her eyes at my request. Then my daughter ordered…she ordered super easy and quick and this employee rolled her eyes at my daughter too. Then when she brought the food to our table…she was still so rude. The pizza was amazing even though the 3 ingredients I had asked to not be on my pizza, were still on my pizza and my wings were definitely not extra crispy. So she gave us all the attitude and was so rude and then still didn’t do what we asked. Our total bill was $120 for 5 people and we were happy to pay it knowing the food was delicious. The rude employee is something that we have not encountered being in Columbus. The other employees were amazing, helpful, kind,...