OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Domino Park — Restaurant in New York

ATTENTION MANAGEMENT:

A bunch of us came to this location on Sat. 7/6 after dinner and this place was a mess. Used napkins on the ground in random locations on the floor, all but one napkin dispenser had 6 napkins left in the entire place, the rest were empty. All the sample spoon handles were sticky, YUK!, all the counter surfaces were sticky and unkempt. It felt like a McDonalds in there. It’s sad to see one of our favorite spots looking like this. Especially since there are other options like Gentile Gelato that is just up the block. Also, the service could’ve been a lot better especially since no other people were on line. What the 2 ladies served up was just a pulse and the bare minimum. Pleasant people should be hired when they’re the face of your business. At $10 a head for ice cream, you can do better for...

I walked by on my way to Domino Park and it immediately caught my attention. They have scoops, an ice cream flight (6 scoops for $11), pints, etc.

I got the flight (yes to myself) and I had grasshopper (9/10), chocotorta (7/10), bubblegum pop (10/10), something passion fruit (7/10), journey to outer spice (7/10), and I can't remember the others.

The people working there were helpful and patient, plus photogenic lol

Most of the flavors I got were vegan and you would never be able to tell the difference! Much less bloated than usual bc of that even after...

I don’t know why this shop keeps hopping to different locations because the ice cream is so effing good. The flavors are incredible... like... incredible. I had a lemon shortcake flavor, and my mom had a chocolate & strawberry lemon sorbet together... mind blown!

The servings are also not shy & the staff is super helpful and polite. The vibe of the shop wakes you up too as it’s very bold, and of course they have pints to go! Definitely worth it and this new location should really stay put because it’s right across from the park etc. so it’s...