La Mercerie — Restaurant in New York

La Mercerie in New York City is a hidden gem that deserves every bit of its five-star rating. From the moment you step into this charming establishment, you are greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for an extraordinary dining experience.

The ambiance at La Mercerie is simply enchanting. The elegant and minimalist decor, inspired by a classic French cafe, creates a sense of timelessness and sophistication. The soft lighting, the beautiful floral arrangements, and the cozy seating arrangements all contribute to an atmosphere that is both intimate and welcoming.

Now, let’s talk about the food. La Mercerie’s menu is a true culinary masterpiece, offering a delightful selection of French-inspired dishes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. Each dish is thoughtfully crafted with the finest ingredients, showcasing the chef’s impeccable attention to detail and commitment to quality.

Whether you’re a fan of traditional French cuisine or looking for a modern twist, La Mercerie has something to satisfy every palate. The croissants, freshly baked and buttery, are a perfect way to start your day. The quiche Lorraine, with its flaky crust and rich filling, is a savory delight. And let’s not forget about the heavenly pastries and desserts - the tarte tatin and the chocolate mousse are simply divine.

What sets La Mercerie apart is not just the exceptional food, but also the impeccable service. The staff is attentive, knowledgeable, and always ready to provide recommendations or answer any questions you may have. The attention to detail and genuine care for each guest’s experience is evident in every interaction, making you feel like a valued guest from the moment you walk in.

In addition to the culinary delights, La Mercerie also offers an impressive selection of beverages. From expertly crafted coffees to a curated wine list, there is something to complement every dish and enhance your dining experience.

Overall, La Mercerie in New York City is a culinary haven that deserves every accolade it receives. With its enchanting ambiance, exquisite cuisine, and impeccable service, it is a true gem that will transport you to the streets of Paris. Whether you’re looking for a cozy brunch spot or an intimate dinner setting, La Mercerie is the perfect destination for a five-star experience that will leave you wanting to come...

⸻

The ambiance, I must admit, was indeed charming. However, having had the privilege of dining at numerous esteemed establishments across the globe, I regret to say that I could not, in good conscience, award more than two stars.

From the very moment we approached the entrance, the experience began to falter. The hostess, bearing neither a smile nor any semblance of warmth, addressed us in a manner that felt rigid and cold—almost as though burdened by personal discontent.

Whilst we awaited our meals, it became increasingly difficult to ignore the discordant noise emanating from the staff, whose numbers far exceeded those of the guests—perhaps twenty staff members to merely ten or fifteen diners. The overall impression was less that of a refined restaurant and more akin to a bustling pub.

The appetiser consisted of merely two scallops and came at a steep price of $24. Though the presentation was elegant and sparked hope for what was to come, that optimism proved short-lived.

As you can see from the accompanying photographs, the presentation of the main course fell woefully short of expectations. Had the flavour compensated for the appearance, such disappointments might have been forgiven—but alas, the dish lacked both taste and refinement, resulting in a growing sense of dissatisfaction.

Despite my wish to take my leave, a companion insisted on sampling the desserts. We therefore ordered the crème brûlée and chocolate sorbet.

The crème brûlée tasted no more distinguished than one might find on a supermarket shelf, and the sorbet was such a poor imitation that it left me questioning whether the chefs truly understand what a sorbet ought to be. It bore the unfortunate taste of ice cream repeatedly thawed and re-frozen, lacking all freshness and finesse.

One is left to wonder how such an establishment continues to operate—perhaps due to sheer luck, or the constant influx of visitors lured by attractive photographs yet unfamiliar with fine cuisine. Or perhaps it is sustained by patrons who care less for culinary quality and more for high ceilings and social media opportunities.

Naturally, no venue is without its imperfections, yet if one aspires to longevity, then true attention must be paid not to flattering reviews, but to the constructive criticisms which point the way toward genuine...

Popped in here midday to treat my sister to some bubbles for all her good work as an aunt, having read all about the special champagne bar that uses unique glassware for the drinks. Imagine my surprise when the bar was closed--even after I'd emailed them two weeks earlier to ask about it and never got a response.

Not off to a great start. Hosts were friendly enough, but it seemed that the only seats available were seated in a steaming hot rays of sunshine, a nicety for hothouse flowers and other greenhouse staples, but not so nice for two siblings whose favorite color is black. We had a few rounds of bubbles and cocktails, all of which were perfectly nice, along with some bread and cheese which was good, if eye-poppingly expensive, even for us.

Service felt like we were being helped by the bus boys (again, friendly enough), a strange decision considering how quiet it was in the restaurant and how definitely-not-cheap everything was. At one moment, my sister observed an idling staff member picking their nose. Nice.

The nifty twist of La Mercerie is supposed to be the housewares section in store, where you can pick up glassware from the aforementioned closed specialty bar and other--surprise--pricey items. It's definitely worth a look if you're headed down Houston, although it's small (or curated, as a PR rep would say).

I'm not the target demo for places like La Mercerie, but judging on the scant clientele, pricing, and slightly aloof service, I'm not sure who is. European tourists? Wannabe-rich housewives? The blind who won't observe errant nose picking?

Maybe I'll swing by again for a proper lunch or dinner to see if there's more heft to La Mercerie than my first impression suggested--but only if I can be sure their champagne...