Brick 3 Pizza — Restaurant in Milwaukee

We stopped into Brick’s Pizza in Milwaukee because their sign said they had authentic New York pizza — and they absolutely delivered! This is my favorite style of pizza, and it did not disappoint. We tried the pepperoni, pepperoni & sausage, cheese, and BBQ chicken pizzas, and they were all fantastic.

I asked about a meat lover’s pizza, and they said it would take about 20 minutes to make. I joked that maybe I’d get one if I was still hungry after my other slices. We sat down and enjoyed the food in a really friendly, welcoming atmosphere — the staff was outstanding.

The highlight? After I finished my two slices, one of the staff members brought over a fresh meat lover’s pizza — on the house — just because he knew I wanted to try it. That small act of kindness really made our day and was such a memorable part of our trip.

Great pizza, amazing people, and a place we’re so glad we found. Highly recommend stopping by if...

I was there one Tuesday, June 13th at 7:53 to pick up an order for a 14inch pizza and mozzarella sticks. The menu says five mozzarella sticks and I received four. This is the second time this has happened, I confronted the young gentlemen with short hair and tattoos on his neck, his name is Shane. His response was we changed the quantity but haven't updated the website. Then he went on to say that I ordered off of eatstreet orders and no quantity is listed, therefore I am wrong. I showed him their home meau, which lists the quantity of mozzarella sticks and he said I can talk to the owner, Demetrius, but gave me no number. I am very disappointed because this is great pizza but the staffing is terrible. For anyone who orders from 1107 N old world 3rd street in...

Real New York-style pizza in Milwaukee. The slices huge and delicious, with a huge variety of toppings available. The traditional Pepperoni pizza is spectacular, and the offbeat Mac and Cheese pizza was so good I went back for a whole pie a few hours later! What’s especially awesome is that Brick3 pizzas taste perfect and fresh even when reheated the next day, unlike most pizzas. The staff are friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. You can enjoy your pizza in the charming NY-chic seating area, or choose at the viewing window and grab a slice/pie to go. Look up and spot their huge collection of...