The Lost Turtle — Restaurant in Charlotte Amalie

I stumbled upon The Lost Turtle after spotting their hilarious “Adult Daycare” sign — and I’m so glad I followed it! I went with my dad and my 1.5-year-old, and we all truly enjoyed our time there.

From the moment we arrived, the two owners made us feel like family. They shared their story, their roots, and what inspired them to open this laid-back little slice of paradise. You can really tell how much heart they’ve poured into this place.

They’ve thought of everyone: 🪝 Hooks and mini-hooks games 🎨 A cute coloring/art area for kiddos 📺 Big TVs for catching the game 🍹 And most importantly — the drinks!

The margaritas are AMAZING, and if you’re into rum, you have to try their rum flight featuring pours from Jamaica, Barbados, USVI, and Haiti.

The vibe is relaxed and tropical — kind of like an old Key West feel, where locals and travelers blend together over good conversation and even better drinks.

If you’re in St. Thomas, make The Lost Turtle part of your stop. Go for the drinks, stay...

We found this incredible gallery & bar while visiting downtown St. Thomas. Walking by, the gorgeous photography hung on the walls caught our attention and drew us in. Once inside we discovered incredible drinks and amazing people! We spent the rest of our short stay in St. Thomas hanging out at The Lost Turtle getting to know the owners, Ben, Natalie, and Jay, admiring the beautiful art, and enjoying the potent drinks from Keith behind the bar. We fell in love with this place and cannot wait to return in April and visit once again with the amazing owners and staff. If you need food, they offer food from Gladys’s right next door. The Lost Turtle is a MUST VISIT location while...

An air conditioned and colorful one stop shop! Get souvenirs, kindness, and a mean rum punch (free sample at the door, $5 at the bar)! They sell amazing jellyfish prints, have a 'husband daycare', and they have everything you'd need to enjoy the island for the day or longer. Perfectly placed right near the cruise ship doc and the Pink Palm Hotel.

Two couples from the States brought their vision to life and you can feel the passion. The games at the tables encourage you to stick around, as a solo traveler I took my punch to go but I felt warmly welcomed and encouraged to return.

Good luck to this team, I'll be back for another rum punch! Follow my channel for...