Forty Deuce Pizzeria & Bar — Restaurant in Columbus

My father and I visited Forty Deuce Pizzeria & Bar with high expectations, but unfortunately, it didn't live up to the hype. We were both eager to try this place but left disappointed, and we won't be returning.

We ordered THE FUHGEDDABOUDIT! which is their meat lovers pizza, featuring pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Canadian bacon, salami, mozzarella, and tomato sauce. However, the pizza we received was missing the meatballs. When we asked our server about it, we were told they no longer serve meatballs. It would have made sense to update the menu to reflect this change.

The pizza itself was just alright—nothing special or worth returning for. Additionally, we arrived around the time they opened, and the place was empty. While the atmosphere might be fun when crowded, the lack of patrons early on likely contributed to our underwhelming experience.

Overall, Forty Deuce Pizzeria & Bar fell short of our expectations, and we won't be...

I learned about Forty Deuces while reading a Columbus based magazine this morning. Anyway, I decided to visit on the same day. Why? Because of the pictures and what I read about the restaurant. This establishment has beautiful appeal from the outside in and the inside out (intentional). The moment I walked up to it I was taken back of its appeal from the outside. When I stepped in I was blown away! The pictures in the magazine are beautiful but the pics do it no justice. Furthermore, the customer service is outstanding! Our server was rather patient and explained what the restaurant’s menu offers. My first “bite” of this place certainly will not be my last! The first made me say, “Wow oh my…this is really good!” Needless to say, the taste of the pizza is parallel to the service! Please do yourself a favor and treat yourself to Ivan Kane’s...

Most places don’t call themselves a New York Style Pizzeria because it is a high standard to uphold. Either the owner has never been to New York or has never tried their pizza here because it literally resembles a frozen pizza thrown in the oven. As an avid enjoyer of New York style pizza, I can confidently say the pizza at Forty Deuce is nowhere near imitating New York style pizza. You can tell the ingredients are very low quality/mediocre. Normally, I would not be this critical, but for $35 a pie the quality of the pizza does not remotely match the price point. There are many pizzerias in Columbus that offer amazing and unique pies for...