Mikey's Late Night Slice — Restaurant in Columbus

Decided to give this location a try to provide an experience to my little one. Placed order and confirmed with cashier it was okay to dine in. She confirmed it was okay. Noticed several reserved spaces. One booth was open that was filthy. The little one asked the cashier if she could clean it off and she told her no. No line, so I asked her and she informed me to give her a moment. She went to go complain about the request to the lady making the pies. I decided to give it a chance until I noticed her take a family order and another customer with no thoughts on wiping the booth off as we stood watching. I requested a refund and left. When a place shows you they don’t value you and only want your money, don’t put up a fuss. Just request your money and leave, and warn others. Cashier name shows AnnMarie, but nobody had a name tag on to confirm. It was the young black girl with the blond and black low Afro. Ann might have been the pie maker or not there because the girl who helped with the refund wrote Ann on...

Already closing early and you guys just opened??? Clearly states on the website open till 1:30 AM get there at 12 AM and they’re all of a sudden closed? Come on you guys I love Mikey‘s late night slice get your staff in line please. Just wanted a slice of pizza after a long day at work, but I guess that won’t happen now. Plenty of staff

update, unprofessional people here As you can see by the goofy response from the owner. “ Wherever you saw the hours, they were wrong.” they were on your damn website/Apple Maps. It’s not my fault that you Don’t know how to advertise your hours properly.

If you advertise to be open till 1:30 AM, you need to be open till 1:30 AM. It gives you even less of a reason to be closed because you are a new store.

Love to see how fast this place will burn to the ground After seeing all the other...

I stopped in at the Easton Mikey's about a week ago. Not a fan of slice pizza, as you never know how long it's been sitting out. Ordered 2 slices of pepperoni to go. They said it'd be about 6 minutes for another pizza to come out of the oven. Ate one in the car and it was fantastic. Took the other home to my son who re-heated it and said it was really good. Went again the other day for a lunch stop and got one slice that had been sitting out. It was not nearly as good, but it was still pretty decent. It is pricey, and there is no way I'd pay over $30 for a pizza. But a slice isn't too bad...